Single police force for Wales could have serious consequences, says ex-commissioner

News imageGetty Images The back of a police officer's jacketGetty Images
The Welsh government has called for policing powers to be devolved

Cutting the number of police forces in Wales from four to one could have "serious" consequences, according to a former police commissioner.

Winston Roddick said the geography of the country meant a single force would struggle to cover Wales adequately, and the current forces - Gwent, south Wales, Dyfed-Powys and north Wales - are performing well.

His comments come as Met Police commissioner Mark Rowley said the number of forces across Wales and England should be cut from 43 to between eight and 10 - or face failure.

The UK government is considering new boundaries, while the Welsh government has called for policing powers to be devolved because it would be in Wales' "best interests".

Rowley said a new police structure would include support from hundreds of local policing commands.

In January, a white paper was produced, with Rowley believing the current system cannot cope against sophisticated modern criminals without urgent reform.

While Prime Minister Andy Burnham has not spoken publicly about the plans, a Home Office spokesperson admitted "our current model of policing has not changed since the 1960s and is no longer fit for purpose".

"Can you imagine one force covering the whole of Wales, given the length of the country and the time it takes to travel from one end to the other?" Roddick said.

"There is no case, no valid case and no valid arguments in favour of reducing the number of forces."

The former police officer, barrister and commissioner for north Wales said a reduction in Wales would make efficiency worse.

"The consequences are going to be serious, I can tell you," he added.

Supporters of the proposal argue that reducing the number of forces would cut costs, create savings and bring greater consistency across the four existing Welsh forces.

News imageA man with short grey hair smiles at the camera. He is wearing black thin framed glasses and a black pinstripe suit, white shirt and blue tie.
Winston Roddick, former police commissioner for north Wales, said having one force would be inefficient

There is no guarantee such far-reaching changes would lead to improvements, according to North Wales Police's former deputy chief constable Gareth Pritchard.

"There are major changes on the horizon," he told Newyddion S4C.

"We have to remember that larger police forces have not necessarily been successful in terms of performance, discipline or accountability.

"A number of commissioners from smaller rural forces are pushing back and saying - look at our performance, look at our accountability and how we work with our communities."

Now a lecturer at Bangor University, he believes there is a clear need to modernise, and that having 43 forces across Wales and England is not necessarily "effective".

But he said there is a need for certainty and clarity.

As debate over restructuring is expected to continue for months to come, the Welsh government is reinforcing its call for policing powers to be devolved.

It is a call that has previously been made by both Plaid Cymru and Labour governments in Wales and, according to First Minister Andy Burnham, he is "open to that discussion".

News imageGetty Images Police vehicles parked up Getty Images
The prime minister said he is open to discussing devolving policing

Devolution would ensure forces have the consistency and powers they need, according to Dyfed-Powys' police and crime commissioner Dafydd Llywelyn.

"We are not arguing against any of the provisions contained in the white paper," he said.

"What we are asking for, from my perspective as Dyfed-Powys police and crime commissioner, is for those powers to be devolved to Wales.

"If changes are going to come to Wales in terms of police governance, this is the golden opportunity to take the next step, namely devolution."

In August, Burnham said he was open to discussing the devolution of policing to Wales and that the forthcoming changes in the sector presented a good opportunity for such discussions.

That message was reinforced this week by the Cabinet Secretary for Justice Alex Norris.

The Welsh government said it "wants policing fully devolved, enabling us to take decisions which work in the best interests of Wales".

"Whilst control over policing rests in Westminster, we believe that any reforms must be guided by what's going to deliver the best outcome for citizens, that is accountable to local communities, and ultimately makes Wales a safer, better place to live," a spokesperson added.

"The Independent Review of Force Structures should therefore be published so that we can consider its recommendations and implications for Wales."