Neighbour driveway row costs glampsite owner £135k

News imageChampion News A person in a cream-coloured belted cape-style coat, black trousers and black shoes walks through a large black iron gate beside a red-brick and stone building. The person carries a brown leather shoulder bag. Champion News
Glamping site owner Carol Esteban is appealing a court ruling of £135,000 in legal costs

A glampsite owner is challenging a court order to pay £135,000 in legal costs after she tried to block her neighbours from parking their car in their own garden.

Carol Esteban told her neighbours Neil and Nadine Gould that their right to use their shared driveway ended opposite their front door, which would block them from their parking space.

Both sides accused the other of trespassing, while Esteban was accused of using "boulders" to block the couple's access to the shared track.

The Goulds sued Esteban in 2025 and won a High Court ruling enabling them to drive far enough along the track to turn off into their parking space. But Esteban has now appealed that ruling.

In the ruling in July 2025, judge Milwyn Jarman explained how the Goulds' detached cottage, Cwmtawe Villa, Abercrave, near Swansea, is completely surrounded by land attached to Cwmtawe Farm, where Esteban runs her glamping site, which is set over 60 acres.

The properties were once all held by the same owner, but the house was sold off in 1949, with documents relating to that transaction now lost.

However, a 1964 conveyancing document stated that the owners of Cwmtawe Villa could enjoy an "easement" - granting them the right to use a track owned by the farm to access their house on foot or with vehicles.

But a missing letter on a map attached to the document sparked the row over how far along the track the easement ends.

Esteban argued that a thick hedge had surrounded the villa at the time the right of way was granted and that it would have "made no sense" for the right of way to entitle the owners to go any further than the gap in the hedge by the front door.

But Jarman rejected Esteban's argument, and said her assertion "has the potential to lead to impracticability, if not absurdity".

He concluded that the claimants were entitled to a declaration that their vehicular right of way extends to the space at the north side of the villa, where they currently park their vehicles.

Esteban was also handed a £135,000 costs bill.

'No evidence'

Appealing the ruling at London's Court of Appeal, Daniel Bromilow, representing Esteban, said the High Court judge did not come to his decision by interpreting the 1949 plans.

He argued Jarman had determined what he thought the parties should have agreed to in relation to the right of way, and said there was "no evidence" the track shown on the plan extended beyond the front door of Cwmtawe.

He also argued against Esteban being handed her neighbours' cost bill for the case, saying she had "succeeded to a significant extent on her counterclaim", including winning a claim that a new waterpipe had been installed unlawfully on her land by the couple.

Owen Curry, representing the couple, urged the appeal judges to uphold the decision, saying the judge had "reached the right conclusion in the case".

The judges have reserved their decision on the appeal, to be given at a later date.