Calls for stronger protection for Guernsey's trees

News imageBBC A picture of tree with not many leaves on in front of a cloudy grey sky in the background.
BBC
Colin Dodd said said trees lacked "permanent protection"

A charity is calling for more laws to protect the island's trees over fears "a lot of trees" are being lost due to property developments.

Guernsey Trees for Life has written a letter to deputies, seeking stronger legal protection for trees and the environment.

Colin Dodd, from the charity, said there had been about five cases this year and the group wanted some form of "blanket protection" for trees.

Deputy Adrian Gabriel, President of the Committee for the Environment and Infrastructure, said officers had been asked to review the existing tree protection orders procedure to establish whether it remained fit for purpose.

Dodd said tree protection orders tended to be "reactive" rather than "proactive", applying to trees once they were under threat.

"If there's a 200-year-old oak tree on-site, it's very easy just to put a bulldozer in there," he said.

"We all need development, but it needs to be in harmony with our environment.

News imageA man standing outdoors and looking at the camera. Cars are parked behind him. There are also buildings.
Deputy Adrian Gabriel said officers were reviewing the effectiveness of the existing tree protection orders procedures

"It's very easy to give that site a little more thought, jig things around slightly and include that tree or that part of the natural environment within that development."

In its letter to deputies, the charity described the current process as "slow and complex and does not automatically protect trees within new planning schemes".

The charity said it believed trees over a certain size should be protected by default.

"We could exempt certain species of course," Dodd said.

"All we're saying is we need some sort of blanket protection for trees."

Gabriel said his committee was committed to ensuring trees and overall biodiversity were protected to fairly balance environmental, social and economical needs - including the provision of housing.

He said the review of the existing tree protection orders was set to conclude by spring 2027.

Gabriel said one benefit of the process was it allowed islanders to request consideration of the protection of trees perceived to be at risk from development.

"Introducing automatic protection for trees immediately could lead to a need to divert resources to monitor and enforce that legislation, which in the current economic climate may not be available," he added.

"As outlined in our committee work plan, we are proactively working to progress our biodiversity net gain and wildlife legislation as part of the delivery of the States' Strategy For Nature."

Follow BBC Guernsey on X, Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to channel.islands@bbc.co.uk.