Waste firm's illegal wood posed 'serious fire risk'

News imageThe Environment Agency A large pile of scraps of wood in a giant warehouse. It is covered in dust and reaches to the ceiling.
The Environment Agency
The Environment Agency paid repeated visits to CLC Utilities in 2021 and 2022

A waste management firm posed a "significant fire risk" to nearby homes and businesses by having more than 10 times as much wood as it was allowed to handle, a court has heard.

The Environment Agency (EA) visited CLC Utilities in Wallsend multiple times in 2021 and 2022 and repeatedly flagged their concerns to the managers, brothers Gary and John Cook, Newcastle Crown Court heard.

Record Andrew Latimer said the firm had given itself an "unfair" advantage over competitors and a fire would have caused major damage.

Both Cooks admitted operating a regulated facility without a permit over a 16-month period and were each ordered to complete unpaid work.

EA officers first visited CLC's site on Davy Bank on 10 June 2021 after receiving information about the firm, prosecutor Rosalind Emsley-Smith said.

They estimated there to be up to 7,000 tonnes of wood in two "large stockpiles" in the company's main building, with an inspector saying she had "never before witnessed so much waste wood on an individual site", the court heard.

The company had an exemption called a T6 to allow it to handle wood, which was cheaper than getting a full permit, but a condition of which was they could house no more than 500 tonnes of the material over a seven-day period, the court heard.

News imageThe Environment Agency A massive long pile of scraps of wood in a warehouse, the roof of which is supported by a line of metal columns.The Environment Agency
CLC Utilites had far more waste wood than it was allowed

The EA inspector said there was "some" fire detection system but it was "wholly inadequate to deal with the risk the site posed".

A compliance report was issued, with the EA returning to the site 15 days later with firefighters, the court heard.

"Some changes to the stockpiles were observed", Emsley-Smith said, highlighting the creation of fire breaks, but, she added, the new gaps "revealed more waste wood stored behind those initial stockpiles that had previously not been visible".

Officers also saw two vehicles attend and deposit more wood during the visit, the court heard.

Inspectors made regular monthly visits to the site as it had been "identified as a significant fire risk", the prosecutor said.

The EA twice removed CLC's T6 exemption, but the firm just re-registered itself again both times, Emsley-Smith said.

By January 2022, efforts had "clearly" been made to create more fire breaks but "there still remained far too much wood on site", the court heard.

'We tried everything'

Two months later inspectors saw the amount of wood had increased with the fire breaks "filled in" with more wood, meaning the "fire risk persisted", the court heard.

In April 2022, the amount of wood had reduced but was still "well in excess" of the 500-tonne limit, the court heard.

In June there was half as much as there had been the previous September but it was still "illegal", and at the final visit in October 2022 there was "still twice as much" wood as they were allowed, the court heard.

The court heard the company, which had been incorporated in 2018, had ceased trading by 2023.

Gary Cook, 47 and of Hurworth Place near Darlington, told the court the company had been trying to move the wood on but was hindered by clients declining to get involved due to the EA action.

"We tried everything, we tried our best," he said. "Everywhere we turned it was a brick wall and we couldn't get over it."

The firm had got the proper permit by 2023 and still existed only to pay off debts of almost £60,000 for loans and to HMRC, the court heard.

He said he had been following professional advice when he re-registered for the exemption.

John Cook, 41 and from Newcastle, said he had removed himself entirely from the operation due to the harm it was having on his health.

Both said they were in debt themselves.

'Flouted the law'

Latimer said it was a "deliberate operation of a business without a permit" which gave CLC an "advantage over its competitors".

The judge said he accepted it was for the company's "financial survival" rather than greed, but the "harm was real".

Though there was "never a fire", the risk of one and the environmental damage a blaze would caused was serious, Latimer said.

People in nearby houses were also unwittingly put at danger, the judge said.

"Had there been a fire the risk would have been real."

He said the amount of wood was "considerable" and the EA had to devote a lot of time and resources to regularly visiting the site.

"The problems did in fact worsen before real efforts were being made to get that waste level under control," the judge said.

Each brother was given a year-long community order with Gary Cook ordered to complete 160 hours unpaid work and John Cook 140 hours.

If the company were still going it would have been fined £9,500, Latimer said.

Speaking after the sentencing, Gary Wallace, North East area manager for the EA, said the Cooks created a "significant fire risk" and put "other businesses in the area in jeopardy".

"They persistently flouted the law, which is there to protect people and the environment," he said.

Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.