Officer in tears as she admits errors connected to fatal crash inquiry, hearing told
Social mediaA police officer broke down in tears as she admitted errors in her assessment of the risk of one of three young women reported missing who was involved in a fatal crash.
PC Lauren Livingstone is one of two officers facing gross misconduct allegations over her actions before a car carrying five people was found crashed in St Mellons, Cardiff, on 6 March 2023.
Eve Smith, Rafel Jeanne, and Darcy Ross all died in the crash. Sophie Russon and Shane Loughlin survived.
The three women were reported missing to Gwent Police on 4 March, and Livingstone said she could not remember whether searches had been carried out at the homes of Sophie Russon or Eve Smith, maintaining her account since March 2024.
PC Richard Hardwick, who also faces gross misconduct allegations, appeared before the same panel and denied the allegations against him.
In evidence Livingstone said she had undergone a three-year policing degree as well as being a special constable for a year before starting with Gwent Police in October 2021, meaning she was still in her probation period when the missing person's investigation happened.
In the official section of the missing person log about houses searches at Smith's house, which Livingstone filled in hours after the visit in 2023 she wrote: "Nothing missing out of the usual.
"Mum and dad was concerned and mum believed she went out in the same clothes and has not taken any new clothes with her."
Barrister Stephen Morley, for Gwent Police's professional standards department, said that was "misleading" and "dishonest", as it suggested a search had taken place.
Livingstone rejected the suggestion and repeatedly said she could not remember whether searches had happened or not at the house of either of woman.
But she said the entry was "awful".
"It doesn't say yes and it doesn't no - it is really poorly written, I fully accept it is really poorly written."
Livingstone also said she had filled in the form as she always had, but the panel heard the police watchdog had assessed her entries in previous missing person investigations and that 80 percent of the time, she had made clear whether a search had taken place or not.
Morley said she had been "deliberately vague", which the officer rejected.
Social MediaLivingstone was then asked about her risk assessment of Smith as a missing person where she answered "no" in the section about whether the 21-year-old's disappearance was considered out of character.
The officer wrote: "They have gone out to what appears to be a party and stayed out longer than what they should have been.
"There are videos of the girls on Snapchat together and they appear to be in high spirits.
"The only concerning thing is that they aren't answering their phones."
Livingstone said she knew that Smith often did not answer her phone but accepted she should have answered the question differently.
"Obviously I should probably have put yes for that," she said.
Becoming emotional, she said she could not have foreseen how the situation was going to end for the three young women.
"I would never have thought what happened to the girls happened.
"If I knew that, we would have done everything, but we didn't."
She said: "We are here for them today," referring to the families of the young women.
"I haven't done this to lie or to hurt anyone."
She then described learning that the group of young people had been found in a car crash the following day, with three dead, as she worked a night shift in the custody suite.
"I thought, 'Oh my God, I have just been with them families the night before'," adding it was the first major incident she had been involved with.
"As a police officer you care, that's why you do the job because you care," she said through tears.
If gross misconduct is proven against either officer, they would be dismissed without notice from the force.
The hearing was adjourned, with the panel due to consider its findings on Thursday.
