City traders' fears over Christmas Market 'rest day'

News imageLouis Reynolds/BBC A photograph on Tom Francis from the Millers Haxby food vendor at Shambles Market sporting a navy hoody and a blue denim apronLouis Reynolds/BBC
Tom Francis, from Millers Haxby, says he wants to see better advertising to tell customers other markets are still open

Tuesday saw the shutters stay down on stalls at York's famous Christmas Market for its first ever "rest day" - but independent traders at a nearby market which runs all year round have warned there could be unintended consequences if visitors stay away from the city altogether due to the pause.

Designed to improve accessibility for residents and to allow Blue Badge holders to park in the city centre, the new weekly rest day for the Christmas Market involves closing the festive stalls as part of a trial by City of York Council.

But Finlay Henderson-Howard, of Shambles Kitchen, in the daily outdoor Shambles Market, said he was "not sure" about the rest day pilot and was concerned about its impact on the wider city centre.

He explained that he had been expecting Tuesday to be much busier than normal for the time of year, with people flocking to the city for a Christmas Market which was not open.

However, he said that had not happened, though he added that it could have been down to the poor weather, with heavy rain all day in York.

"We're not entirely sure what to expect," he explained.

"I know it's about accessibility for disabled people. I wonder if it would be more useful to just make the market more accessible in some way, rather than just close it on a day?"

'Negative impact'

Samantha Emerson, who runs The Brunch Wagon at Shambles Market, said the Christmas Market, which runs from 12 November to 21 December, was her "favourite time of year, just not on Tuesdays".

She said she was concerned the rest day would have "a very negative impact" on her business.

"The advertisement hasn't been there to advertise we are still open," she said.

Emerson called on City of York Council to encourage more people to visit the area.

Meanwhile, Tom Francis, of Millers Haxby, serving fish and chips to customers who had braved the rain, said: "Shambles is open every day of the week. It just needs advertising more so everyone else knows we are still open and trading all week."

However, Francis said the Christmas markets in general did have a positive effect, with "increased amounts" of business.

"We've had this place for three or four years now and people flood into the Shambles Market," he said.

"Business here is really good in November and December."

News imageLouis Reynolds/BBC York Christmas market stalls on Parliament Street shut with no trading taking place on a Tuesday Louis Reynolds/BBC
York's Christmas market on Parliament Street, which closes on Tuesdays, will run until 21 December

Councillor Pete Kilbane, City of York Council's executive member for economy and culture, said the rest day trial "makes it possible for everyone to access the city centre at least one day a week in the run up to Christmas".

"This includes blue badge holders, people with hidden disabilities and some residents who find the crowds generated by the Christmas Market can be overwhelming."

Kilbane said the rest of the city centre was "very much open for business on Tuesdays and that, of course, includes our brilliant year-round Shambles Market".

"Along with city partners we have been promoting this message for months now, and there has been significant coverage of this year's arrangements," he said.

"Though the city centre is open throughout the whole festive period, today was the first rest day for the Christmas Market in Parliament Street.

"It is a trial and obviously we will not draw conclusions based upon one day, especially given variables outside our control such as travel disruption and the weather.

"We are keeping the situation under review and welcome and encourage feedback from businesses, residents and visitors."

Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.