Waste firm appeals over £51m recycling scheme damages claim
Getty ImagesWaste firm Biffa is back in court seeking damages from the Scottish government over the collapse of a bottle and can recycling scheme.
The company failed in a previous lawsuit where it sought £51m over lost investments in the deposit return scheme, which was shelved in 2023 amid a dispute between the Scottish and UK governments.
In January, a judge dismissed its claims as "wishful thinking" but Biffa continues to insist that it was misled by ministers, who it says owed them a duty of care, and is appealing in the Court of Session.
The Scottish government urged the court to dismiss the appeal, saying the new points of law raised were "irrelevant".
Biffa had been contracted as the main logistics partner for the deposit return scheme, which would have seen Scots charged an extra 20p for single-use bottles or cans which would then be refunded when they were returned for recycling.
The company said it had signed up on the basis of a 2022 letter from Green MSP Lorna Slater, then a government minister, offering an "unwavering" commitment to the plans going ahead on schedule.
However the scheme was ultimately put on hold following a row with the UK government about internal market rules.
Biffa insists that letter was a negligent misrepresentation of the true situation, and that it had been a "half truth" because Slater had failed to disclose the risk of failing to agree the plans with UK ministers.
Slater told a court hearing last year that then-Scottish Secretary Alister Jack had "single-handedly undermined" the plans "to give the SNP a black eye".
Jack claimed that the Scottish government had been "incompetent" and had been "utterly irresponsible" in not warning Biffa of the risks to the scheme.
Meanwhile the boss of Circularity Scotland, an arms-length body set up to manage the scheme, said he felt "betrayed" because "material facts" had been kept from him.
Getty ImagesIn January, judge Lord Sandison threw out Biffa's £51.4m claim.
He said the way the company had interpreted Slater's letter was "wishful thinking" on a par with trying to turn "base metal into gold".
He said a "reasonable person" could not have believed the letter gave "any assurance as to the legislative sufficiency of the scheme".
He also said Biffa had the chance to ask for further information or query potential legal hurdles before signing a contract, but that "no such inquiries were made".
Lord Sandison also said he believed both Slater and Jack had given evidence "truthfully and in good faith".
Biffa is appealing the case in the Inner House of the Court of Session.
KC Roddy Dunlop said Lord Sandison had relied on three errors in law in his ruling.
He insisted that Slater's letter had given a misleading impression, adding that "a letter of comfort is not binding as a contract, but it is still actionable if it contains a half truth or an implied representation which is false".
He also said ministers should have disclosed the difficulty with internal market rules to Biffa, and that if they had then the contract would never have been signed.
Getty ImagesThe firm is basing part of its arguments on a 2002 case involving the Spice Girls, where the girl band were found liable for breaching a contract with a sponsor after failing to disclose that Geri Halliwell was leaving.
The Scottish government opposed the appeal, saying the new points of law raised were "irrelevant".
Its lawyers said there was evidence from the original hearings that Slater's letter "was not taken at face value" and that Biffa did not read it as a guarantee of delivery.
KC Gerry Moynihan said the firm only signed the contract after it had put mitigations in place, including insurance against delay or cancellation of the scheme.
He also noted that internal emails showed bosses harboured doubts about how prepared Circularity Scotland was to deliver.
He said Biffa "knew there were risks that were outwith the control" of the government, and that Lord Sandison had been correct to conclude that there was no duty of care owed to them.
A written judgement will be issued at a later date.
A UK-wide deposit return scheme is due to come into force from October 2027.
