Why a £1m park project will leave a crumbling wall unrepaired

News imageLaura Divisia A clear blue sky is reflected in the water of the lake below. A wall runs around the edge of the lake with just a couple of feet showing above the water level. The lake is surrounded by grassy fields. Trees and bushes, some with autumn foliage of red and orange, are dotted around the lake and more trees can be seen in the distance across the fields. Branches from a tree near the camera position hang across the top of the picture with the tree's green leaves covering part of the sky.Laura Divisia
Parts of the wall around the lake at Crookes Valley Park have started to crumble away, destabilising the path around the water

Crookes Valley Park in Sheffield is a popular destination for local residents who come to the green space to relax.

But, over recent years, sections of the wall around the park's lake have started to crumble, destabilising the footpaths around it.

Sheffield City Council fenced off the affected areas and began reviewing how best to carry out repairs to the wall.

A meeting this week approved a £1.1m budget for the work - but while one stretch of the retaining wall will be replaced by a new structure, another section will not be repaired.

According to the local Friends group for the park, this was their idea.

The lake, which takes up most of the space within the park's 4.8 hectares (11.9 acres), is a former reservoir, created when the Great Dam was built in 1785.

It fell out of use as the population of Sheffield outgrew its capacity, but the body of water remained.

Adjacent land was designated as Crookes Valley Recreation Ground in the early 20th Century and then became Crookes Valley Park for the Festival of Britain in 1951.

That is when the retaining wall was built, to convert the former reservoir into a boating lake for the festival.

News imageSimon Ogden On the left of the picture, heading away from the camera, a tarmac path runs along the top of a wall next to a body of water. In the middle of the picture a large chunk of the wall has collapsed into the water, taking part of the path with it. At the left edge of the picture a metal fence blocks off the damaged footpath. Tow metal struts can be seen leaning from right to left to prop up the fence.Simon Ogden
Sheffield City Council's report calls for a "permanent solution" to the lake's crumbling retaining wall

Simon Ogden, one of the co-founders of Friends of Crookes Valley Park, says cracks in the the wall began to appear five to 10 years ago but its condition has now worsened significantly.

"Parts started to actually fall in the lake and so the council fenced it off - it's been fenced off now for about two years."

Papers for the council meeting at which the project was approved said that "recent deterioration indicates that a permanent solution is now required".

There are two problem areas: one on the north-west side of the lake and one on the south-west side.

But why did the Friends suggest that only the south-west side should be repaired?

According to Ogden, not only will it save money, it will benefit wildlife.

"You could do this a lot more cheaply if you actually let the bank of the old reservoir re-naturalise and turn into a soft landscaped edge rather than a stone concrete wall."

Ogden believes the park and its lake are an important habitat for birds and aquatic animals.

"We get visits from herons every morning, we get ducks, we get Canada geese and also gulls as well. Coots and moorhen regularly breed on the lake, but it's a relatively hostile environment for them because of these hard walls.

"So creation of this soft bank will give them much more friendly habitats in which to breed and nest more safely."

News imageSimon Ogden An expanse of greeny-grey water takes up the foreground on the lower half of the picture. Across the middle of the picture, a grey-brown concrete wall rises steeply out of the water. A short stone pillar stands upright in the middle of the top of the wall. Parts of the wall are overgrown with bushes with yellow flowers. Tree trunks can be seen growing on the bank at the top of the wall and further into the distance. Where the water meets the wall, a heron stands on a clump of twigs and looks into the distance towards the right of the picture.Simon Ogden
The project aims to remove the steep concrete wall to create a gentle slope into the water to help wildlife

According to the council report, the retaining wall on the north-west side will be removed and the embankment will then be regraded to form a stable landscaped slope integrated with the lake edge.

It will mean the loss of a footpath which runs next to the wall along that section - but there is a second path which can be used instead.

On the south-west side, there is only one path.

To ensure there is still a circular walk around the lake, this section will be subject to more conventional repairs.

The current retaining wall will be replaced with a plastic sheet-piled wall, made of multiple interlocking thin sheets driven into the ground.

The council report acknowledged that replacing both sections of wall would have been a lower-cost option in the first instance but warned that it would require ongoing monitoring and possible future repairs and associated costs.

Ogden agrees that the chosen option makes sense.

"It will be easier to maintain because the reason the walls are collapsing is because of long-term geology of the valley.

"More heavy rain in the winter means that the slope becomes more unstable.

"So if we were to rebuild the wall, we think it'd probably be cracked and pushed out of place again in a few years' time."

News imageLDRS A green grassy bank slopes downwards to the left from the top of the picture where it meets a stepped, two level wall, with a path between the two levels. The lower level of the wall meets the water of the park's lake which looks browny green. Dozens of young people sit, stand and lie all along the grassy bank, the levels of the wall and the path. They are dressed for hot weathershorts or LDRS
Crookes Valley Park attracts crowds, especially in summer, from the housing estates and student accommodation which are located close by

While some might raise their eyebrows at a budget of £1.1m to repair park walls, it is not the most the council has spent on similar projects.

Work to repair leaks at Abbeydale Dam was completed in July at a cost of £1.3m and with ongoing restoration of the site, the overall budget stands at £2.5m.

The money for this kind of work comes from the council's Capital Maintenance Fund of £11.7m. Day to day maintenance for the city's parks, libraries and community buildings costs around £2.5 - £3m each year and is paid for out of revenue budgets.

The local authority also has plans to carry out structural repairs at Abbeydale Weir, Endcliffe Park, Westwood Reservoir, Millhouses Park and Graves Park - but some schemes are further along than others.

The council meeting this week was told that decisions are made based on which are in the worst condition or which parks are best used.

News imageDave Bocking A man with grey hair stands outside, under a grey sky. He looks into the camera and smiles. He has round glasses with a black frame. He is wearing a grey fleece type jumper.
Behind his left shoulder is a metal railing running along the top of a stone wall. Set back from the railing and wall are several brick buildings with several green bushes in front of them. Over his right shoulder is a red brick building with a grey roof and behind that another brick building can be seen. On the far left of the picture, just going out of shot, is a green tree.Dave Bocking
Simon Ogden is a co-founder of the Friends of Crookes Valley Park

Ogden adds: "Crookes Valley is an incredibly well-used park. It's not a very big park but it really is very hard-working.

"So even though sort of about two thirds of it is water, the rest of the park attracts a lot of people to jog, play in the playground, play bowls, have picnics in the summer, and then kayakers come and wild swimmers use it regularly every day.

"We just look forward to seeing the details and the start of work."

The repairs are expected to start in July 2027 and be completed two months later.

Additional reporting by Local Democracy Reporting Service.

Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North