Ministers approve two controversial electricity substations

News imageBBC An electricity tower with a lattice work of steel and six "arms" holding electricity cables. BBC
SSEN Transmission said the substations were needed to strengthen Scotland's electricity network

Scottish ministers have granted permission for two controversial SSEN Transmission electricity projects that were opposed by local authorities.

In December, Highland councillors refused consent for a substation at Carnaig, near Bonar Bridge, after local residents said it would turn their small community into an "industrial wasteland".

The following month, councillors opposed a substation proposed for Fetteresso Forest, near Stonehaven, after Aberdeenshire Council received more than 2,000 letters of objection.

SSEN Transmission, which appealed against the councils' decisions, said the facilities were "nationally significant" and had been subject to "careful and thorough" consideration.

Highland Council's north planning meeting voted 9-5 to refuse consent for the Carnaig plans after hearing locals' concerns and responses from representatives from the electricity company.

Councillors were told the substation would take five years to build and involve hundreds of vehicle movements each week near a primary school.

Shona Paterson, a local community council member, told the meeting that traffic levels would be "diabolical" and the area would become an "industrial wasteland".

SSEN Transmission said measures would be in place to reduce the impact of traffic and its staff had visited the primary school to inform the pupils about road safety.

The substation forms part of the proposed Spittal-Loch Buidhe-Beauly 400kV overhead line.

The Fetteresso Forest plans also went to a vote but it resulted in a tie.

Committee chairman Alan Turner had the casting vote and decided that the application should be refused.

He raised concerns the 400kV facility would "drastically" change the landscape.

'Energy security'

SSEN Transmission said the substations would help strengthen Scotland's electricity transmission network and connect more homegrown renewable energy.

Director of development Alison Hall said the need for investment in the network had "never been clearer".

She said: "Carnaig and Hurlie will alleviate existing constraints on the grid, help to connect Scotland's abundant renewable energy resources, strengthen our energy security and support the transition to a cleaner and more affordable electricity system.

"They also represent a significant economic opportunity for the Highlands and Aberdeenshire."