Who decides if a game is for adults only?

News imageRockstar Games Two Grand Theft Auto characters flee police on a motorbike, with one aiming a handgun.Rockstar Games
The Games Rating Authority, based in Stevenage, gets to play the games long before release

The latest Grand Theft Auto game brings the franchise's trademark violence and adult storytelling to the latest generation of gaming hardware.

But long before its release, examiners at the Games Rating Authority (GRA), based in Stevenage, Hertfordshire, got to play the game to decide its appropriate age rating.

They analysed its content before assigning a PEGI age rating of 18, which covers 38 European territories.

But who decides a game is for adults only, and how do they make that decision?

News imageGetty Images PEGI icons seen on the boxes of two video games. One is a red 18, the other a green three.Getty Images
The Games Rating Authority administers PEGI age ratings on physical games in Europe

Video games experience a similar process to films shown in UK cinemas, where examiners from the British Board of Film Classification watch each film before deciding its rating.

But rating games presents a unique challenge.

Modern games can contain huge worlds that take months to explore. Some allow players to make their own choices, meaning two people can have vastly different experiences.

Developers first complete a GRA questionnaire disclosing any contentious content and provide at least two hours of footage, along with transcripts of the game's dialogue.

Examiners study this material, logging timestamps for instances of blood, gore, horror, drug use or bad language.

News imageDanny Fullbrook/BBC A young woman with pink hair and thick black-rimmed glasses is sitting at a desk with two monitors, one showing a fantasy character creator. She is in an office and is sitting side-on, smiling at the camera.Danny Fullbrook/BBC
Examiner Sadie West is a fan of role-playing video games

Lifelong gamer Sadie West joined the GRA believing it would be the dream job: being paid to play games.

She says: "I definitely look at it more analytically when I'm playing here.

"Since I've started here, I play games a lot less at home, but because I play in such a different way at work to what I'm playing at home, I can still enjoy it."

West uses her skills with a controller to explore choices and scenarios that developers may not have captured on video.

She says: "Things like, is there an NPC (non-playable character) that I can go up to, and can I attack them? Can I hurt this person? Or what happens if my character jumps off a bridge?

"Sometimes I die on purpose to see what a character death would look like."

News imageRockstar Games A group of bikers ride along a sunlit road past shops and election signs in Grand Theft Auto VI.Rockstar Games
Many games, like Grand Theft Auto VI, feature large sprawling worlds for players to explore

When playing games in her own time West hates hurting NPCs, but admits at work: "Unfortunately I have to be a bit evil sometimes".

She will typically play a game for several days, checking for blood, suggestive costumes and potentially exploitative in-game purchases.

She says: "Once I'm happy that I've seen everything that would impact the rating, I then go through and I write up a report."

That report is kept on record, while a version without plot spoilers is shared online for parents and players to read.

Examiners follow strict classification criteria overseen by a panel that includes child welfare experts and psychologists.

Ian Rice, director general of the GRA, says the criteria ensure ratings are applied "consistently and fairly".

Violence is only one element that is analysed, but shows how context can affect the classification:

  • PEGI 3 & 7: Child-friendly, cartoon-like violence, such as in Minecraft, Rocket League, Roblox or Mario.
  • PEGI 12: Unrealistic violence between humans, this could be games like Fortnite which have no blood or injury detail.
  • PEGI 16: Realistic violence between humans, can include visible blood and pain reactions.
  • PEGI 18: These games include what is classified as "gross violence", with high levels of blood and gore, or violence directed at innocent civilians.

Sexually graphic content and the glamorisation of illegal drug use also trigger an automatic 18 rating.

Some might wonder why games need adult content at all. Rice points out games can cover mature themes just like other forms of storytelling.

He says: "Just because it's in a game doesn't mean somebody's making light of it.

"They can cover serious issues, just like Netflix shows or any other kind of media."

News imageDanny Fullbrook/BBC A man wearing a grey T-shirt with dark shirt over the top is sitting in a warmly lit room in a leather arm chair with the PEGI logo displaying on a screen behind him.Danny Fullbrook/BBC
Games Rating Authority director general Ian Rice says his children have "stolen" his consoles but he gets to "pull rank" to play some games in the office

Since the GRA began administering PEGI ratings in 2012, it has only refused to classify one title, making it illegal to sell it in the UK.

Rice says the authority maintains a dialogue with developers and offers advice throughout the development process.

He says: "That back and forth is really important because they have the opportunity during the development process to change things like the virtual camera angles that particular scenes are shown at, they can cut out words, they can cut out scenes."

Rice himself is a keen gamer, but as a parent he is keen to stress the importance of the age rating system.

Rice adds: "Every child is different, and parents know their children best.

"Our ask is to use the PEGI ratings, the information, and the descriptors to make an informed decision... but if we're rating a game as an 18, we really feel it is only acceptable for adults only."

Do you have a story suggestion for Beds, Herts or Bucks? Contact us below.

Follow Beds, Herts and Bucks news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.