Inquiry chair appointed over NHS trust failings

News imageIson Harrison Twenty-three people, men and women, sit in three rows and look solemnly at the camera. They are in a white room sitting on a grey platform. Most of the people at the front have their hands clasped over their knees.Ison Harrison
Families campaigned for a public inquiry into the NHS trust for many years

The chair of a public inquiry into mental health care at an NHS trust has been named following months of delays.

His Honour Judge John Potter was appointed chair of the probe into serious failings at the Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust (TEWV).

Families, including those of teenagers Christie Harnett, Nadia Sharif and Emily Moore, who died by suicide following care at the trust, previously said they were "in limbo" over the delays.

The inquiry, which starts on Monday and which TEWV said it would fully support, will give "survivors and families the opportunity to be heard and drive urgent improvements", the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) said.

Potter is a retired circuit judge and former deputy judge of the criminal division of the Court of Appeal. He has more than 40 years' experience in public service, the government said.

He said his first priority was to meet and listen to those affected.

"Their voices and experiences will be central to the inquiry's work and will help inform the development of its terms of reference," Potter said.

News imageFamily handouts A composite image showing the faces of Christie Harnett, Nadia Sharif and Emily Moore. Miss Harness has shoulder-length auburn hair and blue eyes. She is smiling at the camera. Miss Sharif has long dark hair and brown eyes. She is looking at the camera, posing with a neutral expression. Miss Moore has long light brown hair with a side parting and brown eyes. She smiles at the camera.Family handouts
The families of Christie Harnett, Nadia Sharif and Emily Moore were among those frustrated by the lack of action

The inquiry, which was launched in December, aimed to establish what happened following "serious failings in mental health care at TEWV, why failings occurred and what needs to change to help ensure patients receive safe, high-quality care", the DHSC said.

Health Secretary Yvette Cooper added the families were "let down" by the trust and had suffered "immeasurable pain".

News imageFamily handout Family photograph of Beth Breach smiling at the camera with long brown hair, hooped earrings and a denim top.Family handout
Beth Breach died while under the care of the trust

Beth Breach, 21, died while under the care of the trust in 2024.

Her family said they believed more could have been done to keep her safe and were still waiting for her inquest and knew a public inquiry could take many years to conclude.

News imageFamily handout Nicola Cunningham sits on a pink sofa. She had long brown hair.Family handout
Nicola Cunningham said the delays meant she "still can't grieve properly"

Her mother Nicola Cunningham said the delays meant she "still can't grieve properly".

"There's a lot of un-answered questions and a lot of frustration and anger. Not having all the answers as to what happened to Beth on that day."

Many families had previously complained about the slow progress and delays that had been encountered since the public inquiry was announced last December.

News imageAlistair Smith stands outside a building wearing a blue suit and red tie.
Solicitor Alistair Smith said he was "tremendously pleased" a chair had been appointed to lead the inquiry

Solicitor Alistair Smith from Ison Harrison, said his company were representing 200 families and individuals who wanted to be involved in the public inquiry.

He said he was "tremendously pleased" a chair had been appointed.

"This is what the families have been campaigning for so long. This is a good moment and we now have movement."

He said while the inquiry would formally begin on Monday, it could be some years before the actual hearings start.

Chief executive of TEWV, Alison Smith, said they welcomed the appointment of the inquiry chair "as an important step forward".

"We acknowledge the significance of this moment for the families and loved ones involved, and we continue to hold them in our thoughts," she said.

"We will co-operate fully with the public inquiry with honesty, openness and humility. We are truly sorry for the times when care fell short, and are committed to listening, learning and continuing to improve."

Lawyers representing those affected previously said they were told an inquiry chair would be appointed by the end of February, along with the terms of reference.

The DHSC said the appointment followed 159 new NHS mental health facilities across England, backed by £343m in funding.

  • If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this article, support is available at BBC Action Line

Follow BBC Tees on X,Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram and listen to Radio Tees on BBC Sounds.