Former MHK questions integrity of election results
BBCThe outcome of a recount of ballot papers cast in a Manx constituency suggests the integrity of this year's general election is "questionable", a former MHK has said.
Following a supervised count, the number of votes changed for five of the six candidates who stood in Onchan in September.
The recount was carried out following a petition by Julie Edge, who lost her House of Keys seat. She said the changed vote totals proved there was a need for a review of the election count process.
Onchan's deputy returning officer Jeremy Callin said it was "probably not surprising" the figures had changed given the "forensic" nature of the recount.
'Verification'
Edge's petition stated that 79 ballots had been unaccounted for.
She said: "The whole exercise of the recount has proven that the integrity of our elections is questionable in 2026.
"We definitely deserve some review of the process and how each deputy returning officer is carrying out the verification, the count, and in my opinion it should be standardised across the island."
Callin is set to compile a report on the recount, which will be submitted to First Deemster Andrew Corlett within seven days.
Amended result:
Rob Callister went from 1,103 votes to 1,184 (up 81)
Gabriella Corkish from 725 to 703 (down 22)
Julie Edge from 866 to 858 (down eight)
Rachel Glover from 1,245 to 1,252 (up seven)
Peter Karran from 738 to 838 (up 100)
Oliver Lockwood unchanged on 50

Edge's petition calls for the court to declare the election void, which would lead to a new election being held.
It argued that although the unaccounted votes would not have changed who was elected, the "fact that ballot papers verified at the count are not accounted for calls the integrity of the count into question".
The recount was once again overseen by Callin, with Edge, the other election candidates, and an independent deputy returning officer in attendance along with members of the media.
Speaking after the process had concluded, Edge said: "There should not be one vote that's not been counted for or counted on the evening.
"The whole point of my petition was the integrity of our democratic process and our right to vote, and for the votes to be counted correctly.
"If we cannot get the integrity for our democracy correct in our main election I really do think that we have issues."
The recount had "made history" as an election petition had never been submitted before on the island, she added.
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
