Yes, you're getting ripped off on Black Friday. These tips will help you spot the bogus bargains
BBC/ Serenity Strull/ Getty ImagesBlack Friday 'deals' can sometimes be price hikes. But there are some easy ways to spot slippery pricing.
We've all heard the siren's call of Black Friday. Deals that dreams are made of. But is it all a mirage?
In many cases, a growing body of evidence says yes. In fact, several pieces of analysis in recent years show that waiting for the "sale" could mean you pay even more.
The European Commission, the progressive US economic policy group Groundwork Collective and the UK consumer group Which? have all uncovered recent examples of misleading price claims during events such as Black Friday and Cyber Monday.
Groundwork Collective, for example, found nearly 30% of the 350 deals it looked at on Amazon from 2024 and 2025 offered no savings whatsoever. About 10% were more expensive than they were in the month leading up to the sale.
Amazon strongly disputes the findings, saying they are based on "flawed methodology and inaccurate data" that is unrepresentative of the majority of its deals and the discounts users saw online. The company also says it has strengthened "guardrails" so that Black Friday 2026 will get you the 30-day lowest price in "almost every case".
But that reassurance will still leave an unsettling doubt in the minds of many consumers, says Elizabeth Pancotti, vice president of policy, advocacy and research at Groundwork Collaborative.
"When Amazon promotes a deal to customers, it should offer real savings," she says. "Customers who are trying to stretch their budgets during the holiday sale should be able to feel confident that if they're being told they're getting a discount, it's true 100% of the time."
The Interface
Want to know more about the stories behind your screen? Check out the latest episode of The Interface, the BBC's flagship technology podcast.
And this isn't just an Amazon problem – there's a war on price tags and the promises they used to keep.
Fortunately, these simple steps can make the job of vetting discounts easier.
How to avoid Black Friday scams
Try a tracker
Free tools like Keepa and CamelCamelCamel track prices at Amazon. Plug-in the URL or product name to check historic prices. They even have automated browser extensions.
Amazon has its own tracker, but it doesn't appear on many products. Panacotti says ignore the reference price you see crossed out on product pages, as Amazon's numbers are inconsistent.
Skip the scroll and trust the experts
Big stores list endless "deals" that may or may not be real, so Pancotti says you may want to resist the urge to scroll so you don't fall for illusions. Smaller retailers with store-wide sales (like 20% off everything) may be a safer bet, but still do your due diligence.
Or let trusted sources do the work. For example, the New York Times' Wirecutter and Consumer Reports (where I used to work) comb Black Friday sales for discounts worth your time.
Pick your battles
No one has time to check every product they buy, and it's easy to feel overwhelmed and just give up. Depending on your budget, gamble on cheap items where it's just a few dollars at stake and save the effort for big and medium-sized purchases.
Try a VPN
With personalised pricing, it's hard to know you're getting a fair price even outside of sales. Try a different browser, switch devices, use a VPN or even check on a friend's phone to see if you're getting squeezed.
Complain as loud as you can
No one I spoke to suggested Amazon is breaking the law. But US law says you generally can't offer a discount that doesn’t exist, says Seth Frotman, a senior fellow at the Berkeley Center for Consumer Law and Economic Justice. The EU is more specific, where sale prices must be cheaper than the last 30 days.
More like this:
But Frotman says regulators need to step up enforcement. "If someone tells you you're getting a deal that doesn't exist, you should be filing complaints with city attorneys, state attorneys general and even the Federal Trade commission where applicable," he says. "It's going to take a lot of individual folks sharing their stories."
--
For more insights, sign up to our Tech Decoded newsletter, where Thomas and Lily Jamali break down the biggest stories of the tech world, and help you live a better digital life. Sign up for free here.
