'An overriding emotion of excitement... 7.5/10' - season report cardpublished at 09:07 BST
Freddie Pye
Fan writer

Image source, Getty ImagesSeason score out of 10 and overriding emotion?
7.5/10. Securing a domestic cup double in a year of much alteration across the first-team squad is beyond a commendable achievement. Pushing a peak, long-term Arsenal project to the limit after a punishing 2024-25 campaign when Manchester City scraped Champions League qualification deserves immense credit, with a premature European exit perhaps standing as the sole blemish. All in all, an overriding emotion of excitement when looking towards the future after what this newly built squad has achieved at its earliest stage of development.
Best moment and why?
Lifting the FA Cup at Wembley was the ultimate poetic finale, beautifully rounding off Pep Guardiola's historic, decade-long tenure with a staggering 20th trophy.
Player of the season and why?
Nico O'Reilly emerged with a breathtaking tactical arc this season across an amazing 53 appearances, seamlessly morphing from a 'traditional' left-back into a powerhouse, box-crashing midfielder, injecting vital defensive steel and attacking potency. That is all before you start taking into account his goals in the Carabao Cup final and away against Real Madrid.
Unsung hero and why?
Nico Gonzalez. When a hamstring injury at Brentford sidelined Rodri for an extended period of time, Gonzalez stepped into the defensive midfield void with maturity and composure we had not seen from him since his January 2025 arrival. While completely replacing a Ballon d'Or winner is an almost impossible task, his controlled play and eye for a forward pass, as well as an iconic FA Cup semi-final winner, kept City's multi-front charge alive until the very end. It was hard not to feel for the Spaniard when he wasn't rewarded with a start in the final against Chelsea.
Biggest disappointment?
Failing to take the Premier League title race down to the final day cuts deep, particularly in the context of matchday 38 being Guardiola's last outing. Repeatedly throwing away advantages and leaking avoidable goals ultimately cost City in their battle with Arsenal, and reversing just one or two of those collapses may have altered the direction of the title.
What needs to change this summer?
Our central midfield because iconic technicians like the departing Bernardo Silva simply cannot be replaced by mediocrity. City cannot afford to cut financial corners here. Investing in the way that brought the likes of Marc Guehi to the backline or Erling Haaland to attack in 2023 is the only path to navigating the post-Guardiola landscape in a role that is so crucial to the way the football club as a whole wishes to play.
Major hope for next season?
To maintain a competitive standard beyond Guardiola's departure. As the legendary coach wisely noted in his farewell comments, happiness shouldn't be entirely conditional on a final trophy lift, and ensuring City remain a profoundly feared, elite force in domestic and European football is the absolute priority under the incoming regime.
Find more from Freddie Pye at City Xtra, external
This is your Manchester City page. Bookmark it and come back for news, fan opinions, punditry and reporter insight, audio clips and more.
If you're on the BBC Sport app, press the bell icon at the top and select news alerts. And don't forget to 'follow' if on the app or signed in on a browser to start seeing more Manchester City content.





























