Kai Fotheringham scored the winning goal for St Johnstone at home to DundeeImage source, SNS
Image caption,

Kai Fotheringham scored the winning goal for St Johnstone

At a glance

  • Campbell gives St Johnstone lead after five minutes

  • Westley levels early in second half after defensive error

  • Fotheringham scores Saints winner in second half

ByCharlotte Cohen
BBC Sport Scotland

St Johnstone moved level on points with fifth-place Dundee in the Scottish Premiership after Kai Fotheringham's second-half winner settled an error-strewn Tayside derby in Perth.

Josh Campbell, on his return to the starting line-up, had St Johnstone in front after five minutes when he headed home Enes Alic's cross.

Simo Valakari's side should have doubled their advantage when Taylor Steven failed to direct his volley on target after Alic's strike was parried into his path.

A fortunate goal brought Dundee level within two minutes of the restart. St Johnstone defender Cheick Diabate clattered into goalkeeper Ross Sinclair, causing him to drop the ball straight to the feet of half-time substitute Joe Westley, who easily slotted home.

But poor defending from the visitors allowed St Johnstone to secure victory. Steven Pressley's side failed to clear their lines and Campbell's blocked shot fell kindly for Fotheringham, who bundled the ball into the net.

Ryan Finnigan thought he had hauled Dundee level when he fired beyond Sinclair from close range, but referee David Dickinson felt there was a foul in the build-up.

St Johnstone also had a goal of their own disallowed when Macaulay Tait tapped in from close range, only to be flagged offside.

Valakari's side remain seventh but are now level on points with Dundee and Dundee United.

Analysis: Fotheringham shines for dominant Saints

Kai FotheringhamImage source, SNS

It was a deserved victory for Valakari's men, their first over Dundee in two years, although it arguably should have been more comfortable.

In the first half alone the hosts had more than 60% possession and 348 passes, almost half of which were in Dundee's final third.

By full-time they had had 17 shots, 14 in the Dundee box. Only four of those were on target and two found the back of the net - had they converted a few more it would have been a more comfortable end to proceedings.

Fans will perhaps point to the decision to leave Josh Fowler, the league's joint-second top scorer with six goals, out of the starting line-up but Fotheringham, on his first start of the season, looked sharp.

The 23-year-old had five touches in the Dundee box, three shots and created one big chance as well as scoring the winner.

To have him back fit, plus a firing Fowler, it may not be long before the clinical edge comes to St Johnstone.

Analysis: Opportunity missed for Dundee

St Johnstone v DundeeImage source, SNS

Despite a brief spell at the start of the second half when Westley's goal restored parity, Dundee never really looked in the contest in Perth.

They had fewer passes, accurate passes and crosses than their opponents.

Besides the goal, which was due to a touch of good fortune, the visitors created very little. They generated an xG of just 0.58, had eight shots and only put three on target.

For Pressley this will feel like a missed opportunity. Had they won, Dundee would have moved up to at least fourth before Falkirk's game at Hearts on Sunday.

Despite the defeat, the Dens Park club remain in a comfortable position heading into the international break with a chance to regroup.

What they said

Figure caption,

We really care about the club - Valakari

St Johnstone boss Simo Valakari: "I'm very, very delighted about our performance.

"We need to remember we played against a very good opponent, they asked many questions of our players but they adapted and found the solutions."

Dundee head coach Steven Pressley: "We were a little bit loose in possession, turned things over on too many occasions.

"I can't complain too much because this group of players have been terrific and sometimes you have to take your medicine and respond, that's what this group do."

Figure caption,

St Johnstone deserved win - Pressley

Player of the match

Number: 18 K. Fotheringham
Average rating 7.61
Number: 18 K. Fotheringham
Average Rating: 7.61
Number: 2 E. Alić
Average Rating: 7.52
Number: 32 J. Campbell
Average Rating: 7.39
Number: 30 J. Cotterill
Average Rating: 7.11
Number: 33 L. Smith
Average Rating: 6.74
Number: 8 J. Holt
Average Rating: 6.57
Number: 20 R. Sinclair
Average Rating: 6.48
Number: 19 D. Finlayson
Average Rating: 6.32
Number: 22 D. Schmidt
Average Rating: 6.30
Number: 7 T. Steven
Average Rating: 6.27
Number: 11 S. Stanton
Average Rating: 6.04
Number: 3 C. Diabate
Average Rating: 6.00
Number: 9 J. Fowler
Average Rating: 5.91
Number: 6 B. Mikulić
Average Rating: 5.80
Number: 25 M. Tait
Average Rating: 5.52

After the opportunity to rate players has closed, the score displayed represents the average from all the submissions by BBC Sport users.