Jamie McGrath celebrates his goalImage source, SNS
Image caption,

McGrath made it two goals in two games after his strike at Hampden last week

At a glance

  • Hibs pick up first league win since 30 August with Pittodrie thrashing

  • Aberdeen make it four losses in past five as manager Robinson feels the heat

  • Reedijk's side move off bottom to 10th as Aberdeen drop to 11th

ByAndrew Petrie
BBC Sport Scotland

Hibernian's crushing four-goal victory over Aberdeen lifted them off the bottom of the Scottish Premiership, leapfrogging their opponents, and piled further pressure on Pittodrie boss Stephen Robinson.

Jamie McGrath's long-range screamer against his former club put Hibs in pole position for their first league win under new manager Marink Reedijk, which was completed in emphatic fashion with goals from Callum Wright, Nicky Cadden and Thibault Klidje.

The victory was Hibs' first in the league since August, with Reedijk building on last weekend's derby triumph over Hearts in the League Cup semi-final.

The irony of McGrath scoring a screamer was not lost on Aberdeen fans, who were unhappy the midfielder left for Hibs after signing a pre-contract in February 2025.

Since his departure, Aberdeen have failed to replace the Republic of Ireland midfielder adequately and that was apparent as they failed to show much quality in attacking areas.

Hibs passed up numerous chances but McGrath's moment of magic just before the hour, as he swerved one into the top corner from 25 yards out, gave them belief.

It looked like substitute Klidje had shown mercy on Aberdeen as he put his one-on-one chance straight at goalkeeper Marius Muller, but Wright was there to place the rebound in from the edge of the box.

A 2-0 loss would've been bad, a 4-0 loss was unthinkable for Robinson. Yet, that's what transpired.

Cadden was able to volley in with his weak foot from a few yards out, before Klidje's fourth in additional time rubbed salt in the wounds.

Analysis: Have Hibs turned corner?

Beating Hearts at Hampden, for the first time ever, was always going to act as a decent springboard for the new Hibs manager.

The things he promised early in his tenure are starting to come to fruition, they just needed a few weeks to bed in.

The passing and movement are starting to click, the quality players within the team are starting to find their level again.

Reedijk was confident it would start to turn around, and the mood of the fanbase has certainly done a 180-degree spin in the past week and a half.

Hibs dominated large swathes of the first half but had to weather a storm just before the break. They did that, denying Aberdeen with a few brave blocks, and in the second half they turned clinical in the second and put Aberdeen to the sword.

At the back, Hibs kept their first clean sheet in the league since April.

The only grievance? Perhaps the international break has come at the wrong time.

FT momentumImage source, Opta

Analysis: Can Robinson survive latest defeat?

Robinson always had a battle on his hands to win over a portion of the Aberdeen fans who were underwhelmed by his appointment. This latest defeat might be the final nail in the coffin.

While the Northern Irishman had worked wonders at St Mirren, winning the League Cup in 2025, his stock was on the way down in March 2026 when he was appointed at Pittodrie.

A league record of six wins from 21 is simply not enough for an Aberdeen manager, especially when you add 11 losses into the mix.

They lacked a clear identity for large parts of this game. Playing with two wide men in Hicham Mahou and Tony Yogane, they struggled to regularly provide service to Kevin Nisbet.

When they did, the Aberdeen captain missed three opportunities - failing to connect with two crosses and cutting back on to his left in the box instead of pulling the trigger.

The closest they came was two Jack Milne chances, as the centre-back rifled one from distance that was well saved, and looped a header onto the bar moments later.

That was during a 10-minute spell in which Aberdeen looked like opening the scoring, but the clinical edge was non-existent. After all, Robinson's side are the Premiership's joint lowest scorers along with St Mirren on 12 goals.

What they said

Figure caption,

'I'll keep fighting until told otherwise'

Aberdeen head coach Stephen Robinson: "The performance isn't acceptable, the result isn't acceptable.

"It's the story of the season - if you don't take chances, you lose matches. They had five opportunities, scored four of them. That's the difference.

"I don't know [what the implications may be for me], I don't make that decision. I'm Aberdeen manager until told otherwise, I'll keep fighting until told otherwise. I can control that."

Hibernian manager Marink Reedijk: "The combination of performance and result is really good. What is also really good is the guys who come on make a difference - Alex Williams had a fantastic match after coming on in 10 minutes.

"It's fantastic how he coped with it and kept on fighting. That's what we need. Also the guys who came on, there are three of them on the scoresheet. That is a good sign."

Player of the match

Number: 17 J. McGrath
Average rating 8.87
Number: 2 N. Devlin
Average Rating: 3.54
Number: 27 M. Müller
Average Rating: 3.50
Number: 22 J. Milne
Average Rating: 3.40
Number: 24 N. Guinness-Walker
Average Rating: 3.22
Number: 17 S. Armstrong
Average Rating: 2.84
Number: 14 H. Mahou
Average Rating: 2.82
Number: 32 A. Aremu
Average Rating: 2.80
Number: 8 B. Lyons
Average Rating: 2.55
Number: 25 C. Ronan
Average Rating: 2.51
Number: 26 D. Happe
Average Rating: 2.35
Number: 7 T. Yogane
Average Rating: 2.26
Number: 11 L. Smith
Average Rating: 2.18
Number: 31 M. Ntelo
Average Rating: 1.97
Number: 15 K. Nisbet
Average Rating: 1.96
Number: 20 T. Olusanya
Average Rating: 1.95

After the opportunity to rate players has closed, the score displayed represents the average from all the submissions by BBC Sport users.