Summary

  1. The Saints March On?published at 21:36 BST 21 May

    Thanks for joining us during the past two days as we have brought you the twists and turns of the Spygate scandal.

    The outcome - Southampton out of the play-offs and fans left questioning the integrity of the club.

    As our Sports Editor Lewis Coombes said earlier: “To try and get that enthusiasm back ahead of next season is going to be a really tough sell for Southampton.”

    You can follow the latest developments on the BBC Hampshire website here.

    But for now, good night!

    A general view during the Sky Bet Championship Play Off Semi Final Second Leg match between Southampton and Middlesbrough at St Mary's Stadium on May 12, 2026 in Southampton, EnglandImage source, Getty Images
  2. Tonda Eckert at the centre of Spygate scandalpublished at 21:30 BST 21 May

    BBC Radio Solent sports editor Adam Blackmore talks to Rob Sills as the findings are released from the Spygate hearing.

  3. Who is Tonda Eckert and can he keep his job?published at 21:14 BST 21 May

    Dale Johnson
    Football issues correspondent

    Just two weeks ago, Tonda Eckert was a head coach who had the world at his feet - tonight things couldn't be more different.

    The German had transformed Southampton from relegation candidates to favourites to win the Championship promotion play-offs.

    And then came Spygate, the explosive controversy which would result in the club being thrown out of the play-offs and deducted four points for next season.

    An independent disciplinary commission found that Eckert had "specifically authorised the observations" and that the club showed a "particularly deplorable approach in its use of junior members of staff".

    The question now is - will he keep his job?

    Read more here.

    Tonda EckertImage source, Getty Images
  4. Southampton's use of junior staff to spy 'morally wrong'published at 20:09 BST 21 May

    Adam Blackmore
    BBC Radio Solent sports editor

    The findings of the commission could hardly have been more damning for Eckert and for the club.

    Eckert, the 33-year-old head coach, has accepted that he specifically authorised observations to obtain information, with the independent disciplinary commission determining that Saints had contrived a plan from the top down with a particularly deplorable approach in its use of junior members of staff to conduct the spying at the direction of senior personnel.

    The commission added that Saints use of junior staff was "at the least morally wrong" adding that those staff were in a vulnerable position without job security and with limited ability to object.

  5. 'Cheating had become accepted common practice'published at 19:30 BST 21 May

    Lewis Coombes
    BBC South Sports Editor

    The fact Southampton manager Tonda Eckert has admitted to seeking specific information about Oxford United’s formation and whether or not Hayden Hackney would be fit for Middlesbrough is a clear indication that cheating had become accepted common practice.

    The fact an intern has spoken of the "pressure he was placed under" provides a damning insight into a culture that no football club will want to be associated with.

    Having authorised what’s been described by the disciplinary panel as a "contrived and determined plan from the top down to gain a competitive advantage", the Saints boss’ position is surely now untenable as the club needs to begin rebuilding its severely damaged reputation.

  6. Southampton's Eckert authorised spying, panel sayspublished at 19:18 BST 21 May

    Southampton's spying on rival clubs was authorised by head coach Tonda Eckert and was a "contrived and determined plan from the top down to gain a competitive advantage", an independent disciplinary panel says.

    The panel also criticised the club's "deplorable approach in its use of junior members of staff" to "conduct the clandestine observation".

    Read more here

    Breaking News graphic
  7. What do Spygate and Swindon Town have in common?published at 18:55 BST 21 May

    Southampton aren't the only team to have missed out on promotion after breaking the rules.

    Media caption,

    What do Spygate and Swindon Town have in common

  8. 'Very difficult' week for Middlesborough bosspublished at 16:47 BST 21 May

    Middlesborough manager Kim Hellberg admits he has "sympathy" for Saints fans.

    Kim Hellberg
  9. 'It's really hard for fans - when your club loses its integrity'published at 14:30 BST 21 May

    Lewis Coombes
    Sports editor, BBC South

    Lewis Coombes

    "The Football Association could still take action against individuals involved in Southampton's spying scandal.

    "The English Football League (EFL) had dealt with punishments affecting the club as a whole, including expulsion from the Championship play-offs and a four-point deduction for next season.

    "But the matters relating to individuals would fall under the FA’s jurisdiction.

    "The written reasons behind the original ruling have not yet been released, but they could help explain why the punishment had been so severe.

    "What we've started to see is the sadness and grief from players and fans.

    “Everyone is questioning those in charge of the club - the very core of the club,” he said.

    "It's really hard for fans - when your club loses its integrity. I've had fans coming up and saying they aren't going to renew their season tickets.

    “To try and get that enthusiasm back ahead of next season is going to be a really tough sell for Southampton.”

  10. Could Southampton players leave in the aftermath of Spygate?published at 12:25 BST 21 May

    Saints players in red and white celebrating on the pitchImage source, Getty Images

    Could Southampton players look to leave the club after the Spygate saga denied them the opportunity to potentially play in the Premier League?

    Geoff Cunningham, a former legal chief at the EFL and now the sports partner at law firm Clarion, told the Press Association the club had "acted in bad faith" and breached league regulations.

    "In doing so, [Southampton] have affected the players’ chances of earning their maximum remuneration packages out of their contract, so on the face of it, there is a form of breach of contract.

    “One thing I imagine Southampton needs to be very careful of, and protect heavily against and defend heavily, is any notion that that potential breach of contract is severe enough to enable that player to terminate their contract, then making them a free agent to disappear into the summer window,” he added.

  11. Ticket refund information for Saints fanspublished at 12:07 BST 21 May

    Fans walking to St Mary'sImage source, Getty Images

    Southampton FC has said it has begun the process of issuing full refunds for all tickets and official travel bought by fans for the Championship Play-Off Final.

    A statement said: "Refunds will be returned to the original method of payment.

    "Due to the volume and following advice from our ticket provider, we understand that refunds should be in fans’ accounts within 10-14 working days."

    It said booking fees would also be refunded.

  12. Saints and Sinners: What we know about Spygatepublished at 10:47 BST 21 May

    Southampton will now miss out on a game dubbed the richest in world football, with the winners of the play-off final guaranteed a minimum £110m in Premier League broadcast revenue.

    What rules did Southampton break?

    The EFL charged Saints with breaking two regulations.

    • EFL Regulation 3.4, which requires clubs to act towards each other with the utmost good faith; and
    • EFL Regulation 127, which prohibits any club from observing, or attempting to observe, another club's training session within 72 hours of a scheduled match between the two clubs

    Southampton admitted to "multiple breaches of EFL regulations related to the unauthorised filming of other clubs' training", the EFL said.

    Club statement

    On Wednesday afternoon, Phil Parsons, chief executive at Southampton FC said in a statement: "What happened was wrong. The club has admitted breaches of EFL Regulations 3.4 and 127.

    "We are sorry to the other clubs involved, and most of all to the Southampton supporters whose extraordinary loyalty and support this season deserved better from the club.

    "We have provided our full co-operation to the EFL's investigation and disciplinary process.

    "We believe the financial consequence of yesterday's ruling makes it, by a very considerable distance, the largest penalty ever imposed on an English football club."

    Fans reaction

    Fans have been reacting to the news since Wednesday morning.

    "The fans are suffering because of their stupidity," said Mike Ross, one of the many Saints fans across the city struggling to digest the news.

    "They should have known the rules and regulations like everyone else does," he added.

    Margaret Holmes added that she "can't understand why they did it" stating that Southampton is "a good team" that had been doing well.

    "They didn't need to do that," she said.

    What next?

    The decision is final and there is no further right of appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport.

    Middlesbrough, beaten by Southampton in the semi-final, were reinstated and will now play Hull City on Saturday (15:30 BST kick-off) with a place in the Premier League on the line.

    Hull, meanwhile, are unhappy they will have to face different opponents at short notice, with owner Acun Ilicali suggesting the club could take legal action if they lose the final.

  13. More on what FA investigation could lead topublished at 10:24 BST 21 May

    The FA will look into who participated in the spying, assessing the culpability of those who encouraged it or knew it was happening.

    The English Football League, which brought the charges against Southampton, can only take action against its member clubs.

    With the FA now looking into the matter the individuals involved could face charges, and potential bans.

    At the 2024 Olympics, Canada's women's team were found guilty of spying on New Zealand.

    World governing body Fifa banned three members of staff - including the head coach Bev Priestman - from football for a year.

  14. Middlesbrough fans ready for Wembleypublished at 10:05 BST 21 May

    About two dozen people standing in a line outside the stadium. They are mainly looking at their phones. There are red doors behind them and a red sign which reads: "Riverside Stadium."

    Boro fans have joined long queues at the Riverside Stadium for tickets ahead of their trip to Wembley on Saturday.

    The game against Hull kicks off at 15:30 BST.

    Southampton has said it will let fans know about refunds for their tickets as soon as possible.

  15. How will scandal impact Southampton's sponsorship deals?published at 09:44 BST 21 May

    Sophie Law
    BBC News

    A close-up of a Southampton football club shirt with P&O Cruises branding, a Puma logo and a Garmin logoImage source, Getty Images

    The BBC has contacted all of Southampton’s main brand partners for comment and whether they’re reconsidering their partnerships.

    So far, Puma has declined to comment and Lucozade said it would only comment after the appeal, which concluded late last night.

    We will bring you any responses we get today.

  16. FA to investigate Spygate sagapublished at 09:23 BST 21 May
    Breaking

    The Football Association has confirmed it will now look into the whole Spygate episode which could lead to its own actions and punishments.

    A spokesperson said: "We will now investigate, and won’t comment further until we have assessed the evidence."

  17. 'Not sure I will renew my ticket', says Saints fanpublished at 09:10 BST 21 May

    Richard ShelleyImage source, Richard Shelley

    Lifelong Saints fan Richard Shelley has said he is not sure whether he and his wife will renew their season tickets next year.

    He says until the fans "are happy that the people who have tarnished our club's name are removed, you won't be able to move forward".

    He said: "They have no place in our football club and I'm not sure they have a place in football."

    He added that a lot of work needs to be done very quickly by the club to win fans back around.

  18. Promotion will be more difficult next year, says ex-bosspublished at 08:46 BST 21 May

    Nigel Adkins in a suit stood in front of the Southampton crest.Image source, Getty Images

    The integrity of Southampton Football Club has been tarnished and will "take a long time to come back", says former Saints and Hull Manager Nigel Adkins.

    Adkins led the Saints to the Premier League after back-to-back promotions in the early 2010s.

    He said he could not understand why the club decided to spy on training sessions, believing there was very little that could have been gained from it and a lot at stake.

    He said: "The rules come in for a reason so abide by the rules."

    He feels for the supporters of all of the clubs involved, adding that promotion for Southampton will be more challenging next season.

    "It can be really difficult once you come down from the Premier League to be able to get back again. Your best chance is at your first opportunity."

  19. 'It's going to be the fans that take the brunt of everything'published at 08:27 BST 21 May

    Southampton Football Club historian Duncan Holley has called the events of the past few days "the darkest week in our 141-year history".

    He discussed how the fallout is going to impact the fans next season and in the long run, telling BBC Radio Solent everyone on social media is kicking Southampton while they are down.

    "The fans stay with the club throughout their lives, whereas the people who work for the club come and go, and it's going to be the fans that take the brunt of everything," he said.

    Saints fans in the stands in yellow and blue with their hands on their headsImage source, Getty Images
  20. Calls for culture change at Southamptonpublished at 07:58 BST 21 May

    Man behind tree films on iPhone.Image source, Other

    BBC Radio Solent's Southampton FC commentator Adam Blackmore said supporters are overwhelmingly calling for anyone involved in the scandal to be gone from the football club.

    "You cannot rebuild a culture with the same people who smashed the culture in place," he said.

    He thinks more details about exactly who was involved will come out when the findings of the independent commission and the appeal are released.

    Blackmore said he felt sympathy for William Salt, who was tasked with filming Middlesbrough's training session and has become the "poster boy of a football act that has embarrassed a whole football club and its fanbase and that wasn't his fault", adding that he would have been authorised to do the filming.

    He added: "I think there is no doubt in my mind that there will be a chain of people from near the top of the footballing operation, down to the intern at the edge of a tree, who would know what was going on."