Summary

Your views as Michael Carrick sacked by Man Utd

  1. Pochettino finalising Man Utd deal after Carrick sackedpublished at 16:00 GMT 12 November

    Mauricio PochettinoImage source, Getty Images

    This live page has finished updating. Here is a recap of the breaking news.

    Manchester United are finalising a deal to appoint Mauricio Pochettino as their new manager after Michael Carrick was sacked earlier today.

    It is understood current USA national team boss Pochettino will take his first training sessions on either 18 or 19 November after he has overseen two US matches with Haiti during the international break.

    United chief executive Omar Berrada has contacted US officials to confirm the existence of both a £7million release clause and of the Premier League club's intention to activate it.

    United sacked Carrick with the club in the relegation zone and undergoing their worst start to a season in 40 years.

    Former Tottenham and Chelsea manager Pochettino, 54, is set to face Liverpool away on Sunday 22 November (16:30 GMT) in Manchester United's first match after the international break.

  2. 'Not good enough for a club of Manchester United's size'published at 15:52 GMT 12 November

    Simon Stone
    BBC Sport Manchester United reporter on 5 Live

    It's interesting really because [Carrick] was manager at Middlesborough, he did really well right at the start then some of the key players he had were sold, that all went wrong for him and he ended up leaving his job at Middlesborough.

    The feeling was he wasn't that bothered about coming back into management and because of his association with Manchester United, he's a legendary player, won the Champions League, five Premier Leagues, one of the most underrated players of Sir Alex Ferguson's era.

    He carried on being a fan of the club, still lives in the North West of England and the feeling was he wasn't so bothered about going back into management unless a job that he felt he couldn't turn down presented itself and that happened in January when Manchester United needed a temporary replacement for Ruben Amorim.

    He took Manchester Untied into the Champions League when few expected it, third place finish.

    Although there were some people who said he shouldn't have got the job on a permanent basis, the majority felt he'd earned the right for a permanent contract.

    But the brutal reality is that Manchester United have won one game in ten in the Premier League, they're currently in the relegation zone, they're already out of the EFL Cup and it's simply not good enough for a club of Manchester United's size.

  3. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 15:45 GMT 12 November

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Rollercoaster of emotions for me today as always when a change of manager occurs but I'm already at the delusional optimism phase. Why am I like this?

    Owen, Rugby

  4. Pochettino 'makes you believe in a better future'published at 15:40 GMT 12 November

    Guillem Balague
    Spanish football journalist on BBC News

    Pochettino has the charm to make you believe in a better future.

    He's improved the ability of players, when you see Harry Kane at 21 to become what he has is part of that. Son [Heung-Min] was the same, Cole Palmer... All of these players he's helped.

    But also with exciting football. If he manages to do that soon enough, then you'll hear him talk and he'll bring you into this journey. I think everyone will enjoy it and I trust that he'll change the fortunes of Manchester United.

  5. get involved

    Get Involved - 'Just awful from Wilcox and Berrada'published at 15:33 GMT 12 November

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Poch isn't going to be able magic us up a new left back or midfielder. The £17m sacking Carrick and £7.5m to get Poch would have been much better spent on players in January. Just awful from Wilcox and Berrada.

    Paddy, London

    United will probably get worse before they get better. Poch will make them RUN. Players are made of glass these days at United. Injuries will come before January window. United have to give Poch funds in January or we will be talking about a new manager coming in by May.

    Nick, Medellin

    The board only want Poch because he doesn't come with any expectations. He brings with himself quite a low bar, and with the state we are in, if we get worse under him, nothing will happen against him due to the reason that he has no ceiling.

    Aaryan, Northampton

  6. 'A sad but exciting time' for USMNT fanspublished at 15:25 GMT 12 November

    Taylor Rockwell from The Athletic's Total Soccer Show podcast has been speaking about what Pochettino's move means for USMNT: "It's a sad but exciting time, I think Manchester United supporters should feel a glimmer of optimism as naive as that is to say.

    "I think he's been a great coach and I think he will bring in a philosophy and style thats been missing. He'll also bring in an identity and a personality that will be difficult to control from the board and directors.

    "For US fans it's a significant bummer. It's happening at the best possible time, given where we are in the timeline of the cycle.

    "We haven't committed to Copa America, we haven't been announced as a Copa America team yet so theres a long runway to build, it just feels like we were already starting to build and now we're going to have a new manager that's going to require a new evaluation of everything an dit feels like work that's already been done."

  7. Carrick's coaching team also leave Man Utdpublished at 15:09 GMT 12 November

    Simon Stone
    BBC Sport Manchester United reporter

    The remainder of Carrick's coaching team - Steve Holland, Jonathan Woodgate, Jonny Evans, Travis Binnion - have also left the club.

    Holland was United assistant head coach under Carrick while Woodgate, Evans and Binnion were first-team coaches.

  8. 'Pochettino has changed the culture'published at 15:02 GMT 12 November

    Guillem Balague
    Spanish football journalist on BBC News

    Pochettino has changed the culture, which means making people work differently, think differently and molding the squad.

    He's done that with Espanyol, with Spurs and with the USMNT.

    But he's faced people at PSG or at Chelsea, where he was like 'this is not going to work'.

    He's got the experiences of both, which I must say Michael Carrick didn't have, to actually deal with this.

    We all know the ownership situation and the divide with the fans but the clean slate is somebody who's going to look at it with new eyes.

  9. Recap - What we know as Pochettino finalising Man Utd dealpublished at 14:54 GMT 12 November

    Who said the international break was quiet? It's been a very busy day so far with our first two Premier League manager sackings of the season. Here's a recap:

    Make sure you stick with us throughout the day because we'll have plenty more reaction.

  10. Pochettino's first five fixturespublished at 14:46 GMT 12 November

    Manchester United

    Here are Pochettino's first five fixtures as Manchester United boss:

    • Sunday 22 November: Liverpool v Man Utd (Premier League)
    • Wednesday 25 November: Sporting v Man Utd (Champions League)
    • Saturday 28 November: Man Utd v Brentford (Premier League)
    • Wednesday 2 December: Newcastle v Man Utd (Premier League)
    • Saturday 5 December: Man Utd v Coventry (Premier League)
  11. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 14:38 GMT 12 November

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    So Poch stays for the two USA matches against Haiti. Who takes training for the next week ? He can't be in Manchester until 20th and we are away to Liverpool 22nd.

    Norman, Thailand

  12. Robinson unfazed by Pochettino departure talkpublished at 14:30 GMT 12 November

    USA and Fulham defender Antonee Robinson has been talking to the media, and obviously, Mauricio Pochettino was the hot topic.

    Here's what Robinson had to say.

    Media caption,

    Antonee Robinson unfazed by Mauricio Pochettino USMNT departure talk

  13. 'What Pochettino will United be getting?'published at 14:23 GMT 12 November

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Mauricio Pochettino remains a beloved figure at Spurs, where he had an outstanding record of consistency following his appointment from Southampton in May 2014.

    He never finished lower than fifth in any full campaign in charge, including second place behind Chelsea in 2016-17 and third in 2015-16 and 2017-18.

    The one question mark always placed against Pochettino, including when he finished sixth at Chelsea in 2023-24, was an inability to get his teams over the line to tangible success in England.

    Pochettino claimed the first trophies of his managerial career with PSG after leaving Spurs - the 2021 French Cup and 2022 Ligue 1 title - but the club's hierarchy felt that was the minimum he should achieve given the squad at his disposal, and he did not see out his contract.

    In England with Spurs, he was runner-up in the League Cup in 2014-15 and reached the FA Cup semi-finals in 2016-17 and 2017-18. In 2018-19, he reached the Champions League final and the League Cup semis.

    In one season at Chelsea - a loveless relationship in which he could never shed his Spurs connections in the eyes of fans - he reached the FA Cup semi-finals and lost the League Cup final.

  14. get involved

    Get Involved - 'Poch has failed everywhere'published at 14:15 GMT 12 November

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    This was the obvious decision to take, but again it looks like the 'business decision' to appoint Poch rather than reach for someone like an Emery.

    Michael, Nottingham

    Mediocre manager, but so is Pochettino. Would have been better sticking with Carrick. Poch has failed everywhere he has been. They will rue this decision.

    Charlie, Glos

    Someone explain how Poch is the man for the job. Had world class players at PSG and got sacked! Came 3rd in a 2 horse race with Spurs and lost a bunch of Cup finals. Not exactly stellar.

    Trigger, Newport

  15. 'Pochettino and United go back a long way'published at 14:08 GMT 12 November

    Phil McNulty
    BBC Sport chief football writer

    Mauricio Pochettino and Manchester United go back a long way, with the Argentine's name associated with the club since he was spotted leaving a lunch appointment at Scott's restaurant in Mayfair with Sir Alex Ferguson in 2016.

    Ferguson was three years into his retirement, while Pochettino was building his reputation at Tottenham, where he fashioned an intense, all-out-attacking team that the great Scot admired.

    Pochettino called it "a meeting in London between colleagues, between a genius and an apprentice".

    In that moment, a link was forged.

  16. What has Pochettino won?published at 13:58 GMT 12 November

    Mauricio Pochettino has not had a trophy-laden managerial career - not yet anyway.

    In his time at Tottenham, he wasn't able to win a major honour but did reach the final of the Champions League and League Cup.

    He was also beaten in the League Cup final when in charge of Chelsea and also didn't win anything at Southampton.

    But when in charge of PSG, Pochettino did win Ligue 1, the French Cup and the French Super Cup.

    Mauricio Pochettino with Ligue 1 medalImage source, Getty Images
  17. Pochettino has 'the opportunity that he's coveted for so many years'published at 13:50 GMT 12 November

    Guillem Balague
    Spanish football journalist on BBC News

    At PSG, he found that he didn't have enough authority, that destroyed him inside and he had to leave eventually, even though he managed Messi, Neymar and Mbappe to more or less make a team.

    At Chelsea it was a mutual thing, he thought "this is not working, this is not for me".

    He's got the opportunity that he's coveted for so many years, having been friends with Sir Alex Ferguson, having to spoken to Manchester United three times, the opportunity to use that experience and take the club to a new place.

  18. get involved

    Get Involved - Poch is a 'big picture man'published at 13:37 GMT 12 November

    Click 'Get Involved' to have your say

    Poch is well suited to manage this team. He’s come from managing the US team with similar capabilities and potential. Should reach top half of the table be end of season.

    David, Liverpool

    It’s time for Poch to come in and make Old Trafford a fortress again, a big picture man just like Fergie.

    James, Lowestoft

    Poch was a huge success at Saints on a small budget, he should keep Man Utd up.

    Richard, Stavanger

  19. Pochettino has limited time before Anfield trippublished at 13:30 GMT 12 November

    Mauricio PochettinoImage source, Getty Images

    So, Mauricio Pochettino is set to arrive in Manchester to take training on either 18 or 19 November - potentially leaving just three days to prepare for United's away trip to Liverpool on 22 November.

    Yep, should he take the job Pochettino's first game as Man Utd boss would be against Liverpool.

    United then face Sporting in the Champions League in Portugal next Wednesday.

    Their next home match is against Brentford on Saturday 28 November.

  20. Recap - What we know about Man Utd sacking Carrickpublished at 13:24 GMT 12 November

    Just joining? It's been a whirlwind day so far with our first two Premier League manager sackings of the season. Here's what's happened so far.

    Make sure you stick with us throughout the day because we'll have plenty more reaction.