The opening quarter of an hour was largely forgettable as both sides struggled to get in behind their opponent.
A terrific slide rule pass from McEneff in the 16th minute finally bisected the rigid Sky Blues defence with Lusty cutting the ball back from the byeline only for the well-positioned David Toure to head away the ball.
That seemed to jolt the home side into action with only a great tackle by Stephen Fallon preventing Leroy Millar from getting a shot away on goal minutes later.
The pressure finally told in the 23rd minute as Larne cut through Ballymena once more with Millar laying the ball on a plate for Lusty to fire home from six yards.
The hosts looked to be able to slice through their opponents at will, and but for a fantastic tackle by Toure just past the half hour, Lusty would have been in on goal.
Lusty was denied again in the 43rd minute as the frontman got on the end of Aaron Donnelly's low drive across the face of goal, but Walsh did well to block the close range effort.
A minute later, the visitors thought they had got back on level terms following a scramble in front of the Larne goal with Glynn eventually forcing the ball home, but it was quickly ruled out for offside.
Shortly after the restart, Lusty grabbed his and Larne's second of the game as the hosts ripped through the Sky Blues rearguard once more.
Kevin O'Hara eased past Glynn before crossing for the onrushing Lusty to finish past Walsh from eight yards.
Chris McKee should have halved the deficit five minutes later after Caoimhin McConnell picked him out at the far post, but he failed to direct his header on goal.
That was to prove vital as Larne added a third on 62 minutes, as O'Hara turned provider once again, picking out McEneff after getting to the byeline and the midfielder applied the telling finish past Walsh.
Four minutes later, Lusty wrapped up his hat-trick, walking through a Ballymena defence claiming for an offside which never came before slamming the ball past the helpless Walsh to complete an impressive night's work.