Summary

Your views on the England squad announcement

  1. Recap: Tuchel news conferencepublished at 12:00 GMT 6 November

    England

    That's your lot from today's England squad selection live page.

    As always, a live filled with debate after Thomas Tuchel named his squad for the upcoming Nations League matches.

    Here are the top lines from the morning:

    We'll be back shortly to bring you some Premier League news conferences this afternoon so keep an eye out!

    You can read more on Thomas Tuchel's comments with regard to Cole Palmer in our news story, here.

  2. Poll results: 68% agree with Tuchelpublished at 11:57 GMT 6 November

    Just before we head off, it's worth checking in with the poll at the top of the page.

    Sixty-eight percent of you agree that England boss Thomas Tuchel has made the right call leaving Cole Palmer out of the squad, while 32% of you think the manager has got it wrong.

    Who will be right? Time will tell, I guess.

  3. White 'deserves to open a new chapter'published at 11:51 GMT 6 November

    England

    A final word from Thomas Tuchel on the return of Arsenal right-back Ben White and the boos he received from the England crowd in his last appearance in March, after previously making himself unavailable to play under Gareth Southgate:

    "We were not happy about this, although we could understand the disappointment of the fans, of course, with what happened before.

    "I think this is a closed book now because I think everyone could see the investment of Ben and the quality of Ben in the way he presented himself in the March camp before the World Cup.

    "When I speak with him I always feel the hunger from him to come back and the excitement.

    "He missed the last camp. He is the standout player for Arsenal in a position where we struggle with injuries, somehow, and we have a lot of changes.

    "This gives Ben the opportunity to impose himself again. He deserves to open a new chapter and deserves positive feedback from the crowd."

    Ben WhiteImage source, Getty Images
  4. 'We want to set up a final against Spain'published at 11:48 GMT 6 November

    England

    England boss Thomas Tuchel on aims for the rest of the Nations League campaign:

    "Me personally, I am targeting top spot and I would be very surprised if my group isn't. That is clearly the target.

    "We want to have a final [for top spot in the group] in Spain. We want to have these pressure moments, these matches when we play for something. We want to play under pressure and be prepared in the best possible way for the Euros.

    "Croatia is a crucial match to win. We had a freak result [the 7-0 win] which did not reflect the quality of Croatia in general. It was a deserved result but we have to forget that result and remember what we put in. We need another top performance because Croatia showed an excellent response against Spain.

    "We play against two big nations in a short period of time. It is a crucial match in order to have another big one [against Spain] in Madrid."

    Thomas TuchelImage source, Getty Images
  5. get involved

    Get Involvedpublished at 11:46 GMT 6 November

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    If I was Palmer and had been omitted from the World Cup squad in favour of Madueke and Eze, I would also have prioritised my fitness and pulled out in September…

    Albie, London

    Before we demonise Palmer let’s remember than he carried an injury most of last season that impacted on his performance. This season he needs to manage his playing time and hopefully get back to the levels of previous seasons.

    Richard, West Yorkshire

  6. Jobe Bellingham 'one of five central midfielders'published at 11:44 GMT 6 November

    England

    More from England manager Thomas Tuchel on calling up Jobe Bellingham, revealing that he spoke with the Borussia Dortmund player on video message:

    "It's an incredible achievement for the brothers and the family to be both nominated for the national team, which is an incredible story in itself. I was very happy to give him the call-up and I saw his excitement straight away in his smile. He is a very open and calm personality so it was a very nice phone call, of course, because it was very good news."

    On Jobe Bellingham's role in central midfield: "He is one of five players for the central midfield. He is a more defensive player than his brother Jude. Good on the ball, good physique, very physical player who can keep possession. Now it is up to him to impress."

  7. 'We naturally entered a new phase with squad'published at 11:41 GMT 6 November

    England

    England boss Thomas Tuchel on entering a new phase with the squad:

    "I think we did naturally. We were a little bit forced. I was a bit concerned before the last camp because we missed Dean Henderson, John Stones, Dan Burn, Jordan Henderson, Reece James - players who were really responsible for the attitude and the energy at the World Cup and played a huge part in the standards throughout the camp.

    "I was a bit worried that we missed so many of them but the group found a new way. They found new leadership, a new way to engage with each other. We built another camp with a good atmosphere, new voices to set the standards.

    "Now we have more choices and I had to give Dan Burn, Jordan Henderson, Dean Henderson difficult phonecalls. I am very aware of what they did for us and they built a very strong foundation on which these players now are benefitting from.

    "Naturally, we went forward. But we always want to go forward and embrace change as something positive. It does not mean the door is closed for these kinds of players. But we decided to give this group kind of a second push."

  8. 'Alexander-Arnold deserved to come back'published at 11:38 GMT 6 November

    England

    England boss Thomas Tuchel on Trent Alexander-Arnold:

    "He was very good in the last camp and in the games he played, and he deserved to come back.

    "The competition is on, as always. The door is always open. He competes with Jarell [Quansah] and Ben [White] for the right-back position."

    Trent Alexander-ArnoldImage source, Getty Images
  9. get involved

    Get Involved - 'Players who put effort in deserve to be prioritised'published at 11:35 GMT 6 November

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    As much as I love players like Palmer, who can bring some magic... I passionately believe that players who put effort in, and who give good performances (and who make themselves available without issue) deserve to be prioritised.

    Joe, UK

    Comparisons with much greater players like Hoddle aren't relevant. Palmer is a good player, sure. But he's not critical to England, doesn't set the world on fire when he plays, doesn't always make the side and competes against better players.

    GJ, Wiltshire

    I like what Thomas Tuchel says about attitude and character. Chelsea release Rice because he "wasn't good enough", my beloved Irons took him on because of his attitude more than anything. Now he's consistently one of the best in the world in his position, and still improving.

    Neil, Seville

  10. Rogers then Ngumoha - Tuchel on who will play on the rightpublished at 11:32 GMT 6 November

    England

    Thomas Tuchel on who will play on the right side of England's attack:

    "I think it's Morgan Rogers for us and then it will be Rio [Ngumoha] on that side. He played there for Liverpool and impressed in the last camp.

    "Josh King can maybe play there, we will try this, and then Morgan Gibbs-White can play on the wing.

    "We need runners there who can attack through the lines, so I think we have options.

    "It's a close call and difficult decision not to bring Noni [Madueke], but we stick with the group that we had and give them out trust."

  11. 'Dewsbury-Hall is close'published at 11:28 GMT 6 November

    England

    England boss Thomas Tuchel on Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall being left out:

    "He is close. A very good player, a very good season. I see him, in the way we play now, I don't see him in central midfield - more as an eight or a 10, in the finishing part of the game.

    "The competition is very, very high in our squad in this position.

    "As you know he was in our squad of 55 [for the World Cup]. You can see his quality and he was very close."

    Dewsbury-HallImage source, Getty Images
  12. Poll: Should Palmer be in the England squad?published at 11:26 GMT 6 November

    Well you just knew this one was going to cause debate, didn't you?

    We've still got more quotes to bring you from England manager Thomas Tuchel before we close but while we continue to compile them, you can have your say on the Cole Palmer debate at the top of this page.

    Should Cole Palmer be in the squad? Yes or no.

    Have your say and we'll reveal the results before we switch over to today's Premier League news conferences.

  13. get involved

    Get Involved - 'It feels like Tuchel is punishing Palmer'published at 11:23 GMT 6 November

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    Palmer’s omission reminds me of how successive England managers overlooked Glen Hoddle, who was at that time the most naturally gifted yet slightly maverick player in England. People pay to watch players like Cole Palmer. It feels like Tuchel is punishing the lad.

    Tim, Norway

    Cutting through all of Tuchels waffel Cole Palmer has been dropped because he cried off the last squad. Yet Ben White who walked out of the England squad because something upset him is in. For me Tuchel is not that convincing in his explanations.

    Joseph, London

    As a Chelsea fan, I may be biased but I don’t see how Cole Palmer would weaken the England squad from the one selected. Good news for Chelsea, Palmer probably indifferent as only a friendly, Tuchel imitating a headmaster not a great look.

    Ian, Hove

  14. 'It is about the players who walk the talk in camp'published at 11:21 GMT 6 November

    England

    England boss Thomas Tuchel on whether he has any doubts over player fitness and if he has a standby list in case of withdrawals:

    "I have a standby list and the clubs and the players know it, players who cover us on a lot of positions.

    "But we have 22 outfield players so this should not affect us. It is a short camp and we should be fine number-wise.

    "It is always about the ones who are in camp, who don't withdraw and walk the talk, come to camp and show that it matters.

    "I think that [message] is naturally coming through. That was always the message very, very early that is matters if you are in camp.

    "The last camp was an excellent one and the trust and belief is in the players who were there."

  15. 'Mainoo has had difficult spell'published at 11:18 GMT 6 November

    England

    Thomas Tuchel on Manchester United midfielder Kobbie Mainoo missing out:

    "I think Kobbie had a difficult spell with his club and in the meantime it was Jobe [Bellingham] who impressed in the same time.

    "That is what we want. The door is always open for younger players to overtake and make their mark."

    Kobbie Mainoo'sImage source, Getty Images
  16. 'Palmer misses too many opportunities to impress'published at 11:15 GMT 6 November

    England

    More from England manager Thomas Tuchel on Cole Palmer's omission:

    "I guess everyone is desperate to play for England and Cole is no exception. We are speaking now about a player that is not in camp. It counts when you are in camp and I just said last time that he misses too many opportunities to impress. It was a long camp, it was two and a half weeks and the players and the boys who were in camp built something extraordinary.

    "That's why the credit goes to them, the trust is for them. If you are in camp, this is your chance to impress.

    "So it's not personal and of course we will never assume that Cole is not in the mindset to come and desperate to play for his country, but the competition is on and the players who were in camp did an amazing job and kept their place."

    Tuchel later added that the door is always open for a potential return for Palmer...

    Cole PalmerImage source, Getty Images
  17. get involved

    Get Involved - 'Palmer was given chance and decided not to take it'published at 11:14 GMT 6 November

    Click 'Get Involved' at the top of this page to have your say

    Palmer was given his chance and he decided not to take it. In his position he already had players ahead of him. He may drop even further back now, with Josh & Jobe given a chance. Will we see Jude & Jobe play together in this camp?

    Ben, Chippenham

    You want players who will bust a gut to play for their country. Palmer doesn't appear to fall in to that category.

    Chris, Bolton

    Palmer is too selfish. Watch him for Chelsea and he always wants to be the hero and score a worldy instead of playing in a team mate to score and win. England need team players. Bellingham is world class but works for the team as well as himself.

    Adrian, Prescot

  18. 'An extraordinary player'published at 11:11 GMT 6 November

    England

    Thomas Tuchel on England captain Harry Kane, who is set to break the all-time record for England senior men appearances after winning the Ballon d'Or:

    "Just an incredible achievement that these two occasions come together one after the other and we are able to witness this.

    "He wins the Ballon d'Or, deservedly so, and then gets the all-time record for England with 126 appearances in his next England game.

    "It's an important match for us. It is a crucial match for us, to set up a final in Spain after.

    "So it is a deserved frame and a deserved occasion to celebrate an extraordinary player."

    Harry KaneImage source, Getty Images
  19. Jobe Bellingham is Under-21s' 'standout player'published at 11:09 GMT 6 November

    England

    More from England manager Thomas Tuchel on the selection of Jobe Bellingham:

    "First of all Lee [Carsley] is speaking very highly of him for the Under-21s for a while now. He is the standout player. He is the captain of the Under-21s so I think the door should always be open and the pathway should always be open for special performances over a long period of time and that is what Jobe has done.

    "He found his way and his rhythm with Dortmund, where he has had an excellent start to the season. He is a regular starter there and now very influential."

    Jobe BellinghamImage source, Getty Images
  20. 'King gives us a bit of flexibility'published at 11:07 GMT 6 November

    England

    England manager Thomas Tuchel on selecting Josh King: "He is just a fantastic character. He gives us a bit of flexibility.

    "We decided to nominate 22 outfield players for flexibility in training and he is the extra player in training, if you will.

    "He is an exciting player, a versatile player. In pre-season he helped us in training as a full back but we will not do that again.

    "It is the attitude and the personality."

    Josh KingImage source, Getty Images