Summary

Media caption,
Watch: ICJ judge delivers verdict that Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya
  1. Watch: BBC Southeast Asia correspondent reports from Myanmar in 2017published at 12:58 GMT

    Jonathan Head
    South East Asia correspondent

    Back in 2017, I visited the Rakhine state in Myanmar, where hundreds of thousands of people fled to Bangladesh weeks after violence erupted across the country.

    On arrival at Sittwe, the Rakhine state capital, we were given instructions. No-one was to leave the group and try to work independently. There was a curfew at 18:00 local time, so no wandering after dark.

    We could request to go to places that interested us; in practice we found such requests were rejected on grounds of security. To be fair, I believe they were genuinely concerned for our safety.

    The government's purpose in bringing us was to balance the overwhelmingly negative narrative coming from the Rohingya refugees arriving in Bangladesh, who have almost all spoken of a deliberate campaign of destruction by the Myanmar military and Rakhine mobs, and appalling human rights abuses.

    But right away these efforts faltered.

    Media caption,

    Who is burning down Rohingya villages?

  2. Facebook has long been accused of amplifying hatepublished at 12:48 GMT

    We heard earlier the court was not "fully convinced" that Myanmar's army had incited genocide on Facebook.

    This has been a contentious claim for many years.

    In 2021, dozens of refugees in the UK and US sued Facebook, accusing the platform of letting hate speech against them to spread and demanding more than $150bn in compensation.

    The following year an Amnesty report argued "dangerous algorithms and reckless pursuit of profit substantially contributed to the atrocities".

    The refugees' lawsuit was dismissed this spring, with a court finding US law gives protection to online platforms over third-party posts.

    In 2021 Meta said it had built a team of Burmese speakers, banned Myanmar's military and taken "action on harmful misinformation to help keep people safe".

  3. The ICJ can't enforce its guilty rulingpublished at 12:40 GMT

    Anna Holligan
    Reporting from The Hague

    member of Myanmar's delegation sits at her desk during a hearing at the Peace Palace, the seat of the International Court of JusticeImage source, Getty Images

    No state has previously been found responsible for genocide by this court. For Rohingya survivors and the hundreds of thousands living in refugee camps in Bangladesh, it is formal international recognition that what happened to them amounted to genocide.

    Legally, Myanmar has been ordered to stop any ongoing violations, pay reparations to victims, and give guarantees that it will not repeat them.

    But it is important to be clear: this isn't a criminal trial. The ICJ cannot send individual generals to prison. And there's no enforcement mechanism. The court relies on the UN Security Council and political pressure to make its rulings stick. So for many Rohingya, the judgment is hugely symbolic - but it does not, on its own, bring them safely home.

    It also does not directly imprison Myanmar’s commanders: the ICJ adjudicates state responsibility, while the ICC prosecutes individuals.

    But a genocide finding could add legal and diplomatic weight to separate criminal proceedings and to calls for enforcement through the UN Security Council.

  4. Analysis

    What now for Aung San Suu Kyi, or for military leader Min Aung Hlaing?published at 12:33 GMT

    Jonathan Head
    South East Asia correspondent

    A woman looks to the right while speaking into a microphone in front of an all red background. She appears old and has long brown hair, tied back, with a bunch of small white flowers hanging from the side of her headImage source, EPA
    Image caption,

    Aung San Suu Kyi is Myanmar's former head of state

    Where does the ICJ verdict leave Aung San Suu Kyi?

    The ICJ found the Myanmar state responsible for genocide, and Aung San Suu Kyi was the head of state at the time most of the actions cited in the verdict were carried out. Moreover, she chose to lead the initial legal defence presented by Myanmar at The Hague.

    She had very little control over the military forces who launched the attacks on Rohingya communities in 2017, but neither did she criticise their actions; instead she criticised media coverage of the violence, calling it ‘an iceberg of disinformation’.

    She was trying to manage a very delicate relationship with the armed forces, whose commander Min Aung Hlaing did order the attacks on the Rohingyas and who eventually deposed her government and jailed her. That almost certainly inhibited her from condemning her soldiers. But what happened to the Rohingyas, and the ruling now at the ICJ, must forever tarnish her reputation.

    And where does the ICJ verdict leave military ruler Min Aung Hlaing? As the current, contested head of state and the commander of the forces who carried out the actions now legally ruled as genocidal, his should be the reputation most affected by the verdict. It comes just as he is trying to repair his international image following his catastrophic coup in 2021.

    The ICJ did find that inflammatory statements made by Min Aung Hlaing at the height of the anti-Rohingya operations in early September 2017 did not amount to genocidal hate speech. But of all the people involved in the persecution of the Rohingyas in 2017 he must surely be the most culpable.

    However his reputation in most of the world is already so bad this verdict cannot make it a lot worse, and among Asian countries now interested in normalising relations with Myanmar a genocide verdict in the Hague may not matter that much.

  5. What we heard in court as Myanmar found guilty of genocide against Rohingya Muslimspublished at 12:29 GMT

    Three people wearing black and white judges robes sit behind a bench at the end of a court room. A quarter of the logo of the United Nations is seen on the front of the bench.Image source, AFP via Getty Images

    Over the course of nearly three hours, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) has set out its findings on whether Myanmar carried out a genocide against its Rohingya Muslim minority.

    In a landmark finding, the ICJ found the state guilty and outlined Myanmar's violations of the Genocide Convention. Here's a recap of what we've heard:

    • The judge recognised attacks from the Rohingya militant group Arsa leading up to August 2017, but said Myanmar security forces "killed thousands of Rohingya civilians" as they sought to flee to Bangladesh
    • The ICJ determined that around 10,000 Rohingya were "violently killed during clearance operations" in 2017
    • Judge Iwasawa Yuji said there had been "reasonable inference that Myanmar security forces acted with genocidal intent"

    We'll be bringing you more analysis on this ruling over our coming posts - stay with us.

  6. Myanmar violated order to preserve evidence, court decidespublished at 12:27 GMT

    President Iwasawa told the court that Myanmar violated an order to preserve evidence.

    By 11 votes to four, the court finds Myanmar violated its obligation to prevent the destruction and ensure the preservation of evidence related to alleged genocidal acts.

    It was ordered to do this by the ICJ in January 2020.

    That was the final decision reached by the court, and the session has ended. We'll bring you a recap of what we heard in our next post.

  7. Myanmar obligated to compensate Rohingya, court rulespublished at 12:12 GMT

    The judge reads out the 10th and 11th decisions.

    • By 10 votes to five, the court decides that Myanmar is under obligation to compensate to the Rohingya group and its members for the violation of its obligations to prevent genocide
    • By 10 votes to five, the court decides that the amount and modalities of compensation and other reparation due to the Rohingya group should be settled by the ICJ
  8. Court says Myanmar must give assurances it won't repeat violationspublished at 12:07 GMT

    Now for rulings eight and nine:

    • By nine votes to six, the court finds Myanmar must "provide assurances and guarantees of non-repetition of the violation of its obligations" under the Genocide Convention and prevent similar violations from happening in the future.
    • By 10 votes to five, it decides Myanmar must adopt "measures of restitution" as laid out in the judgment - we'll know exactly what this means once we've seen the full text
  9. Court finds Myanmar violated obligations under Genocide Conventionpublished at 12:06 GMT

    Judge Yuji continues, reading out the fifth, sixth and seventh decisions:

    • By 14 votes to one, the court finds that Myanmar has violated its obligation to enact the necessary legislation to give effect to the provisions of the Genocide Convention
    • By 14 votes to one, the court decides that Myanmar must cease any ongoing violation of its obligations under Article 5 of the convention on the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide by enacting legislation
    • By 13 votes to two, the court decides that Myanmar must take immediate and effective steps to investigate "all persons reasonably suspected of having committed acts contrary to Article 3 of the convention" on the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide in relation to the 2017 clearance operation
  10. A scene of celebration at Rohingya refugee camp in Bangladeshpublished at 11:57 GMT

    We've been following the scene at a Rohingya refugee camp in Bangladesh, where a large crowd of people were watching the verdict being delivered on a small screen.

    Since the verdict found Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya group, men have jumped to their feet in triumph.

    A young man lifts his hands in the air in celebration amongst a crowd of Rohingya refugees watching the verdictImage source, EPA/Shutterstock
  11. Myanmar failed in its obligation to punish genocidepublished at 11:54 GMT

    ICJ Judge Iwasawa reads out the fourth decision.

    By 11 votes to four, Myanmar is found to have violated its obligation to punish genocide and other acts listed under article three of the Genocide Convention.

  12. How the ICJ voted: Myanmar guilty of committing and failing to prevent genocidepublished at 11:54 GMT

    We're now going through each of the rulings in turn. Below were the judgments from the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in relation to the first three motions:

    • By nine votes to six, the ICJ finds that Myanmar has "committed genocide against the Rohingya group in northern Rakhine state"
    • By nine votes to six the court finds that Myanmar has violated its obligation to prevent genocide by individuals alongside its security forces
    • By 14 votes to one the court finds that Myanmar has not publicly incited genocide against the Rohingya group in the "northern Rakhine state"
  13. Ruling a 'long-awaited recognition of Rohingya's suffering' - Human Rights Watchpublished at 11:47 GMT

    Human Rights Watch says the ICJ ruling is a "long-awaited recognition of the suffering the Rohingya have endured from Myanmar’s military".

    "The ruling also provides a significant precedent for victims of genocide, and other grave crimes, across the world in their own quest for justice," senior international justice counsel Maria Elena Vignoli says.

    Vignoli adds that Myanmar should "swiftly comply with the court’s judgment and end its oppression of the Rohingya", and that "concerned governments" should "ensure the safe and voluntary return of Rohingya refugees to Myanmar".

  14. Verdict was reached nine votes to sixpublished at 11:43 GMT

    The verdict was reached by nine votes to six - with nine judges agreeing with the genocide verdict and six against it.

  15. ICJ finds Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingyapublished at 11:37 GMT
    Breaking

    The International Court of Justice finds that Myanmar has committed genocide against the Rohingya group in northern Rakhine state.

  16. Myanmar has obligation to make reparations to Rohingya victims, judge sayspublished at 11:31 GMT

    The court finds Myanmar has an obligation to make reparations for its actions, but has not specified the specific amount, Judge Iwasawa says.

    He says that restitution should be proportionate to harms, but that "The question of amount or modalities of compensation... should be determined in a subsequent stage of the proceedings".

    Myanmar should, within two years of this judgement, create a report about how it will adopt restitution, Iwasawa adds.

    The Gambia submitted that Myanmar is obliged to provide "full reparation to all Rohingya victims with punishable acts".

  17. Judge: Myanmar failed to punish genocidepublished at 11:25 GMT

    Myanmar has failed to investigate, prosecute and punish people, including commanders, who committed offences under the Genocide Convention's Article 3, says Judge Iwasawa.

    Article 3 of the Convention says genocide, conspiracy to commit genocide, direct and public incitement to commit genocide, attempt to commit genocide and complicity in genocide should be punishable.

    Iwasawa also adds that "Myanmar has failed to punish genocide under Article 1, 4 and 6 of the Genocide Convention".

  18. Myanmar destroyed evidence by burning bodies and bulldozing - judgepublished at 11:12 GMT

    Judge Iwasawa says Myanmar engaged in "extensive destruction of evidence" by burning bodies or disposing of them in other ways.

    It also burned and bulldozed sites where "clearance operations" took place, he says, obstructing any effective investigation into what happened in 2017.

  19. Court 'not fully convinced' Myanmar incited genocide on Facebookpublished at 11:05 GMT

    The court considers that some Facebook military messages "sought to encourage the non-Rohingya population to engage in violence against the Rohingya as a group", the judge says.

    But the court does not think the posts "were made with a specific intent to destroy the group in whole or in part... or that the intended audience would have understood the messages as such".

    The court is therefore "not fully convinced" that Myanmar was "directly and publicly inciting genocide against the Rohingya by private actors".

  20. Myanmar has long said Rohingya aren't a distinct grouppublished at 11:00 GMT

    Jonathan Head
    South East Asia correspondent

    Successive Myanmar governments have long insisted the Rohingya are not a distinct ethnic group, and therefore should be regarded as Bengali migrants from Bangladesh.

    The 1982 citizenship law recognised 135 ethnic groups as citizens but did not recognise Rohingyas as a distinct group, thus excluding them from citizenship.

    This resulted in them being subjected to a range of discriminations like freedom to travel, freedom to marry and freedom to register the birth of children.

    Rohingyas had enjoyed some recognition prior to the 1982 law. These days nearly all Rakhine Muslims self-identify as Rohingyas, and winning equal recognition to other Myanmar groups as citizens with equal rights has been a core Rohingya demand.

    Notably, ICJ judge Yuji Iwasawa identified the Rohingya as a distinct ethnic group when delivering his findings earlier today - noting that they have a distinct language, art and self-identify.

    There is evidence that they have been discriminated against by Myanmar "for decades", he added, and they qualify as a protected group.