Summary

  1. UK 'simply not prepared' for coronavirus pandemic, inquiry findspublished at 14:39 GMT 19 November

    Ella Kipling
    Live reporter

    Man in high vis jacket with NHS Test and Trace written on it stands next to an entrance sign. He has his back to camera.Image source, Getty Images

    Today’s report was a damning one, with the inquiry's chair, Baroness Heather Hallett, stating that the country was "simply not prepared" for the coronavirus pandemic.

    She said that the effects of the virus might not have been so severe had there been "better pandemic planning", and laid out five key failings, while also sharing nine recommendations.

    As part of those recommendations, Baroness Hallett stressed the need to create a "single, integrated, UK-wide test, trace and isolate system" for future public health emergencies and to ensure there are plans for financial support in place if self-isolation is needed.

    Campaign group Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice UK said the government needs to get prepared for the next pandemic - a view shared by experts such as Professor Christina Pagel, who told the BBC that we need to be learning from Covid-19, rather than forgetting it.

    That brings out live coverage to a close, but you can read more on this story here.

  2. In many ways, there was little surprising in herepublished at 14:21 GMT 19 November

    Nick Triggle
    Health correspondent, at the inquiry

    This is the seventh report of the Covid inquiry and all but one - the fourth on vaccines - have been highly critical.

    In many ways, there was little surprising in here. The failures in testing were apparent very early in the pandemic - after all the UK abandoned community testing in March 2020 just as a virus was beginning to spread - and that was despite pleas from the World Health Organization to “test, test, test”.

    At the time that was a major embarrassment, the UK had boosted it had world leading public health measures in place.

    In time the four nations of the UK developed comprehensive test and trace services. But at huge cost - more than £30bn was spent during the pandemic.

    The UK had done pandemic planning ahead of Covid 19, but had planned for a mild flu one rather than something like the virus that emerged.

    Other nations, particularly in the south east Asia region, which had experience of Sars, adopted a different approach with more robust measures. The challenge now is ensuring the systems in place are flexible enough to meet the demands of a future pandemic.

  3. Testing facility closures 'damning indictment' of pandemic response, university professor sayspublished at 14:07 GMT 19 November

    A yellow sign with testing and a black arrow on it in a car parkImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Several temporary testing centres were set up, including drive in ones

    Professor Alan McNally, from the University of Manchester, says that scientists across the UK tried to tell the government that emergency measures, such as the use of university laboratories, would be needed to offer early testing during the pandemic.

    He tells the BBC: “Sadly that advice was rejected or ignored.

    “It’s emotional to think if we hadn’t been ignored, what the impact might have been in the early days of the pandemic in the UK.”

    All of the UK's large testing facilities have been dismantled, which McNally says is a “damning indictment of our response to the pandemic”.

    He warns that the UK now has “zero ability to ramp up testing quickly” should another pandemic occur.

  4. 'Lack of testing capacity hamstrung us from the beginning', says professor who gave evidencepublished at 13:56 GMT 19 November

    Professor Christina Pagel, who gave evidence to the inquiry, says the lack of testing capacity is what drove the UK’s pandemic strategy.

    But she adds the UK’s strategy should have been driving testing capacity, and that lack of testing “hamstrung us from the beginning”.

    Pagel, a professor of operational research, tells the BBC that another part of the issue in the UK was the lack of financial support offered to those needing to isolate.

    She says countries which offered higher rates of pay during isolation had “much higher rates of adherence” and that, as a result, the UK “never had people really able and willing to isolate”.

    Looking to the future, Pagel says it is "frustrating" that people want to put Covid behind them, saying people need to learn from it and put the inquiry's recommendations into practice.

  5. Analysis

    The missing pieces from the test and trace jigsawpublished at 13:38 GMT 19 November

    Nick Triggle
    Health correspondent

    The NHS Covid-19 app on a tabletImage source, Getty Images

    Once NHS Test and Trace got going in May 2020, it ramped up testing capacity incredibly quickly - arguably faster than any other nation in the world.

    At its peak it was processing more than 800,000 PCR lab tests a day as well as sending out and recording hundreds of thousands of lateral flow tests that gave users immediate results.

    But evidence presented to the inquiry during the hearings last year were critical of the service’s ability to do its other functions. Testing is just one part of the jigsaw - it can only help contain the spread of the virus if contact tracing and isolating is effective.

    There were delays reported in identifying the close contacts of those who had tested positive, while a lack of financial support was blamed for people not isolating - it took until September 2020 for a £500 payment to be made available for those on low incomes.

  6. UK 'not prepared' for testing and tracing during pandemic, report finds - a recappublished at 13:26 GMT 19 November

    Freya Scott-Turner
    Live reporter

    Two white boxes on a pub table. The one on the left is for customers to place their NHS test and trace form in. The other, which is smaller and shaped more like a tray, is for disposable food menus.Image source, Getty Images

    A new report by an inquiry into the UK government's response to the pandemic has been critical in its assessment of how testing, tracing and isolation was carried out. If you're just joining us, here is the latest:

    • What's been happening? The UK Covid-19 Inquiry has released its report on testing, tracing and isolation during the coronavirus pandemic. It's the seventh out of 10 - see our earlier post for what the other reports said
    • Remind me, what was test and trace? During the pandemic, millions were told to stay at home if they’d been in contact with someone who tested positive for the virus. The systems differed across the UK
    • UK 'not prepared': The report - which is critical - says that a lack of pre-existing test, trace and isolate systems left the UK "effectively blind" to how fast Covid-19 was spreading
    • Five failings with a 'terrible human cost': Overwhelming of the testing system, a lack of financial support for people self-isolating, and confusing public messaging were some of five key failings that the chair points out, external
    • Recommendations: The report also makes nine recommendations, and particularly stressed the need to create a "single, integrated, UK-wide test, trace and isolate system" for future public health emergencies
    • Group urges government to 'act now': Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice UK says the inquiry has "exposed the lies and incompetence that left thousands of us grieving" and calls on the government to "act now"
  7. Campaign group urges government to 'act now'published at 13:08 GMT 19 November

    Campaign group Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice UK says the inquiry has “exposed the lies and incompetence that left thousands of us grieving loved ones who should still be here”.

    The group says that government failures, such as the slow testing rate and sidelining of local public health teams “cost lives”.

    It calls for ministers to “fund a permanent testing network, give local teams the staff to trace outbreaks, and ensure anyone asked to isolate can afford to stay at home.”

    The group says: "Our loved ones paid with their lives for the last government's failure to prepare.

    "This government must act now, while it can still spare others that loss. We cannot wait for another pandemic to rebuild the systems needed to protect us."

  8. Government 'under-used local council expertise', LGA sayspublished at 12:59 GMT 19 November

    The Local Government Association (LGA) says the inquiry is right to recognise that the government under-used councils’ contact tracing expertise.

    After councils were brought into the response, local contact tracers used their knowledge of the area, door-step visits and trusted relationships to "reach people the national system had missed", Cllr Eamonn O’Brien, chair of the LGA, says.

    This shows that closer working between local and central government on public health is “vital” to strengthen future pandemic preparedness and response, O’Brien adds.

  9. Border control plans and a UK-wide test and trace system: The report's recommendationspublished at 12:46 GMT 19 November

    Baroness Hallett walking past a black metal fenceImage source, PA Media

    In her report on testing, tracing and isolating during the Covid pandemic, inquiry chair Baroness Hallett makes nine recommendations.

    1. Monitoring the UK's testing capabilities to ensure that the diagnostic sector is used effectively
    2. Ensuring that plans are in place to deliver manual contact tracing on a large scale
    3. Developing a UK-wide digital contact tracing tool
    4. Making sure that local plans are in place to deliver practical support to communities if self-isolation is required
    5. Having plans for financial support in place if self-isolation is needed
    6. Planning for the use of international border controls
    7. Developing aligned communications campaigns about testing, tracing and self-isolation - to "avoid confusion or ambiguity"
    8. Improving data collection and evaluation of testing, tracing and isolation so that both impact and levels of adherence in the general public can be monitored effectively
    9. Hallett says these recommendations support her ninth recommendation: the development of a "single, integrated, UK-wide test, trace and isolate system" for future public health emergencies
  10. Inevitable delays carried a 'terrible human cost' - Baroness Hallettpublished at 12:38 GMT 19 November

    Inquiry chair Baroness Hallet says the UK’s “fundamental lack of pre-pandemic preparedness” led to inevitable delays, which carried a “terrible human cost”.

    She has identified five areas where failures occurred:

    1. Testing - Demand for testing “completely overwhelmed” the supply and processing of the tests, she says. Governments were forced to pause testing across the wider community, which meant decision makers were “effectively blind to the true spread of the virus”
    2. Contact tracing - Public bodies were “wholly unprepared to deploy contact tracing at the scale required” and it wasn’t until the summer of 2020 when widespread contact tracing was established. At this point the virus had “already swept through the population unchecked”
    3. Self-isolation and support - Baroness Hallet says many people were faced with the “difficult choice” between losing their income or risking spreading the virus. She says targeted financial and practical support should have been introduced earlier
    4. Public communication and data - The “proliferation of messaging” was often conflicting and confusing, which undermined public trust and compliance
    5. International borders - The lack of any systematic border control measures until the summer of 2020 placed the UK in an "extremely vulnerable position"

  11. Report calls for development of UK-wide digital contact tracing toolpublished at 12:33 GMT 19 November

    Paris Gourtsoyannis
    BBC Scotland political correspondent

    Protect Scotland App on smartphoneImage source, PA Media
    Image caption,

    The Protect Scotland app used during the pandemic

    The inquiry report calls for the development of a single UK-wide digital contact tracing tool, after criticism that a separate Scottish Covid app wasn’t compatible with one developed for use in England.

    The use of different apps in the four nations of the UK "introduced the potential for confusion" and complicated infection control, with communities in border areas highlighting issues with having to use two different systems.

    The Scottish government initially planned to use the Covid app developed by the UK government, but started planning its own app over concerns about a lack of communication around technical details, and fears that Scottish health officials wouldn’t be able to make changes to reflect differences in policy.

    The Protect Scotland app that was eventually rolled out only supported contact tracing, while the UK government’s app for England also allowed users to "check in" to venues, check symptoms and link to test bookings.

  12. Why the UK should have been better preparedpublished at 12:24 GMT 19 November

    Nick Triggle
    Health correspondent, at the inquiry

    Unlike the UK, places such as Hong Kong, Australia, South Korea, Singapore, Taiwan and Germany had more robust test, trace and isolate systems in place when Covid hit.

    This helped, initially, to slow the spread of the virus.

    Southeast Asian territories had learned from outbreaks of Sars and Mers, the inquiry’s report says.

    Australia and Germany had heeded lessons from elsewhere.

    The UK, by comparison, didn’t.

    And this is despite the fact it ran a series of simulation exercises in the years leading up to the Covid pandemic.

    These included Exercise Cygnus into a flu pandemic and Exercise Alice into Mers.

    Both identified problems relating to test, trace or isolation, which appear not to have been fully acted on.

  13. Lack of preparation forced government to use harsher methods, Baroness Hallett sayspublished at 12:20 GMT 19 November

    Baroness Hallett has short blonde hair and wears a black jacket and white scarfImage source, UK Covid Inquiry

    We're now hearing a video statement from inquiry chair Baroness Hallett, who says that this report focuses on "one of the most critical aspects" of the government's pandemic response: testing and tracing.

    These systems are "nothing new", Hallett says.

    She says that "history has shown us time and again" that "prompt, accurate" testing can be used to identify when viruses are present in society.

    Because the UK was "simply not prepared", she says that governments were "forced to use harsher measures" such as lockdowns or school closures.

    "Too many died without the comfort of their loved ones around them, countless families were left grieving," she says.

    These effects "might not have been so severe" had there been "better pandemic planning", she adds.

  14. Border controls ‘critical gap’ in UK defencespublished at 12:16 GMT 19 November

    Chloe Hayward
    Health reporter, at the inquiry

    The report states that the UK “lacked a clear strategy for implementing border control measures early in the pandemic,” which left the UK in an “extremely vulnerable position.”

    Although the closure and restriction of borders was noted as "immensely complex", the inquiry said that border control measures could serve as an important tool “to reassure the public and increase confidence.”

    By April 2020, 93% of countries had put measures in place - such as flight suspensions, border closures and travel restrictions - to control their international borders.

    By contrast, the UK government only requested travellers arriving from high-risk areas to self-isolate for 14 days.

    The UK government implemented no further border control measures until June 2020.

    The report says that border controls were a "critical gap in the UK’s ability to limit the spread of the virus” and recommends that in the future “international border control measures should be in place at the earliest stages of a pandemic to attempt to control the spread of infection into the country”.

    AA picture from Heathrow airport in January 2021 - the UK was about to close so-called "travel corridors" with countries, from which arrivals were exempt from quarantineImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    A picture from Heathrow airport in January 2021 - the UK was about to close so-called "travel corridors" with countries, from which arrivals were exempt from quarantine

  15. More should have been done to help people self-isolatepublished at 12:11 GMT 19 November

    Nick Triggle
    Health correspondent, at the inquiry

    Even with effective test and trace systems in place, those identified as at-risk of infection or confirmed as infected needed to isolate.

    But in the early months of the pandemic, estimates suggested less than half of people were complying with the rules.

    Ministers and their advisers discussed this and fines of up to £10,000 were introduced for those who did not comply, which some experts have said was counter productive.

    Changes were made to allow people to claim statutory sick pay.

    But it was not until September in England - and later in Scotland and Wales - that £500 financial payments were introduced to help those on low incomes to comply.

    More also needed to be done to provide practical support for things such as collecting medicines and shopping for food for those who did not have people to call on.

  16. Inquiry chair speaking now - watch livepublished at 12:08 GMT 19 November

    Baroness Hallet, who has presided over the Covid inquiry, is now speaking following the release of the inquiry's findings on test and trace.

    You can watch live at the top of this page.

  17. Could the end of community testing have been avoided?published at 12:05 GMT 19 November

    Nick Triggle
    Health correspondent, at the inquiry

    In mid-March 2020 the four UK nations took the decision to end community testing, focussing it instead on hospitals and care homes.

    At the time, the World Health Organization was urging nations to “test, test, test”.

    The explanation from the government was that there was not enough capacity in publicly-owned labs, it was relying on a network of 12.

    In time 10 huge Lighthouse labs were built, allowing the UK to develop one of the biggest testing infrastructures per head of population in the world.

    But they took months to build. Was there an alternative?

    Largely unbeknown to senior government decision-makers, testing at the time was overseen by the arms-length Public Health England, there was also significant capacity elsewhere, including in the private sector and universities.

    The report stops short of saying this would have solved the testing crisis, but it certainly poses the question.

  18. The UK 'was simply not prepared' for the Covid-19 pandemic, inquiry sayspublished at 12:01 GMT 19 November
    Breaking

    Nick Triggle
    Health correspondent, at the inquiry

    The UK was effectively blind to how quickly Covid was spreading in the early days of the pandemic because it did not have robust test, trace and isolate systems in place, the official inquiry says.

    The seventh report of the Covid inquiry said as a result, the virus spread across the country virtually unchecked for the first few months.

    These failings - alongside others - meant the four UK governments were repeatedly forced to resort to harsher measures including lockdown and school closures.

    Inquiry chair Baroness Hallett said the UK should have been better prepared - and learnt lessons from other countries who had experience of dealing with outbreaks of other infectious diseases such as Sars.

    The report lamented the fact that despite UK scientists developing a highly accurate test for Covid in January 2020, the government was forced to abandon community testing in March that year at a critical moment as the virus was spreading.

    The lack of practical and financial support to help people self-isolate was also criticised - it took until September 2020 to introduce £500 payments in England for those on low incomes, Scotland and Wales followed suit in October and November.

    The report also said that the UK lacked a clear strategy for implementing border control measures early in the pandemic, leaving the country in an “extremely vulnerable position.”

    By April 2020, 93% of countries had put measures in place - such as flight suspensions, border closures and travel restrictions.

    By contrast the UK government only requested travellers arriving from high-risk areas to self-isolate for 14 days. It implemented no further border control measures until June 2020.

    Hallett said: “Test, trace and isolate systems are nothing new. Unlike vaccines and treatments, which take many months or even years to develop, test, trace and isolate systems can be deployed rapidly. They are a vital line of defence.

    "The UK was simply not prepared. Too many lives were cut short.”

    This Flourish post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.

  19. Covid inquiry report on test and trace about to be releasedpublished at 11:57 GMT 19 November

    The latest report from the UK Covid-19 Inquiry is about to be released. It's examined the approach to testing, tracing and isolation during the pandemic.

    From 12:00 GMT, you’ll be able to read it in full and you can watch a statement from Inquiry chair Baroness Hallett at the top of this page shortly after it comes out.

  20. Testing community better prepared for another pandemic - test company founderpublished at 11:51 GMT 19 November

    Jim Reed
    Health reporter

    People all wearing white in a lab work at desks
    Image caption,

    A high-tech manufacturing plant on the outskirts of York now has 10 times the capacity

    The main point of this whole inquiry is to better prepare the country for the next pandemic that might come along.

    Earlier this week I went to a biotech park on the outskirts of York to see what's changed since Covid.

    An old grain storage site has been converted into a high-tech manufacturing plant for cheap lateral flow tests.

    Here they design and make kits for other companies to quickly test for everything from cancer markers to the signs of heart disease.

    Each shift now has the capacity to make 100m tests a year, 10 times more than before the pandemic.

    The firm's founder, Dr Chris Hand, told me that technology has improved to make tests more sensitive and easier to use.

    "So I think we are better prepared than we were last time both as a company and across the testing community," he said.