Summary

  1. Case highlighted 'woeful deficiency' in postpartum healthcare, Clancy's lawyer sayspublished at 20:47 BST

    Reddington says the trial of Lindsay Clancy has shed light on postpartum issues and women's healthcare more broadly.

    This case shows "the woeful deficiency that women have they are pregnant, when they have babies, and God forbid when they are on medication because of postpartum psychosis".

    He says he hopes that there is societal change and that it "it might be the spark that lights the fire".

    Remember: Clancy's legal team argued she was not guilty of murdering her children because she was suffering postpartum psychosis at the time. Prosecutors argued she was not suffering psychosis and she was aware of right and wrong at the time.

    Read more here: Lindsay Clancy's trial puts postpartum psychosis in the spotlight

  2. Clancy 'will be ready' for potential retrial in the autumn, lawyer sayspublished at 20:28 BST

    Reddington is asked about previous comments that his client Lindsay Clancy was not emotionally ready to deal with a new trial.

    "Judge Sullivan is indicating that we are looking at sometime in the fall," Reddington says, referring to a possible new trial that could be coming.

    Prosecutors have said they're still unsure if and when they will retry the case.

    "She will be ready," Reddington says.

  3. Would have been a verdict if not for the one juror singled out in the note, Reddington sayspublished at 20:26 BST

    Asked how Clancy is, he says "not good", and asked how her parents are, he says "not good".

    "If we didn't have that one individual, we would've had a verdict and we would be out of here," he says.

    Reminder: We don't know how the jury was split or what deliberations looked like in the room.

    Reddington adds that the district attorney should "revisit his facts and figure out whether or not he can prove the case" on a retrial.

    Though he had tense exchanged with the judge in court, he described Judge William Sullivan as "wonderful".

    He emphatically tells the group of press: "We will be back."

    Read more about Reddington, Clancy's attorney known for firey exchanges in court, external.

  4. Clancy's lawyer says he 'crushed' the government's casepublished at 20:20 BST

    Kevin ReddingtonImage source, Reuters

    We're now hearing from Lindsay Clancy's lawyer Kevin Reddington, who is speaking outside the courthouse.

    "Obviously this is not a time for gloating, bragging, expressing victory. It's a very sad case," he says.

    He said he "crushed" the DA's case, and thanked the members of the jury "minus one".

    "I'm representing a woman who is a fantastic, wonderful individual," he says of Clancy.

    He describes Clancy as "brave", saying she is loved by everyone.

    "Nobody had anything bad to say about her except the two prosecutors," he says.

  5. What happens now?published at 20:14 BST

    Media caption,

    Watch: What is a mistrial and what does it mean for Lindsay Clancy?

    A few different things could happen now that a mistrial has been declared.

    The prosecution can choose to refile and restart the trial with a new jury. While prosecutors almost always ask for a retrial in serious felony cases like this, the district attorneys say outside the courthouse that that's a decision they are not yet ready to make.

    Prosecutors could also negotiate a plea agreement with Lindsay Clancy.

    Alternatively, prosecutors could dismiss the charges altogether, though that does not seem likely as they appeared eager to book the next trial status date, now scheduled for 29 September.

    If a new trial is planned, Clancy will remain in the same forensic mental health facility she has been in - though her defence attorneys could ask for a review of her bail situation, said Heather Cucolo, a New York Law School professor and expert in mental health law.

  6. Not clear which way the jury split, says prosecutorpublished at 20:09 BST

    Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz is asked by press: Do you think that another jury could be convinced of Clancy's guilt, if 11 of these 12 jurors were not?

    "We don't know what they believed or didn't believe," Cruz says of the jurors.

    We know the jury has told the judge three times that they are deadlocked in their decision, but we don't know what position any member of the jury has taken or what talks looked like in the deliberation room.

  7. Trump weighs in on Clancy mistrialpublished at 20:05 BST

    Bernd Debusmann Jr
    White House reporter

    While the court drama is taking place in Massachusetts, President Donald Trump is at the White House and taking questions from reporters.

    One of the reporters asked him if he'd been following the Clancy trial.

    In a brief answer, Trump called the case a "horrible tragedy" and said he was aware that it was likely to end in a mistrial.

    "I assume there's going to be another trial," he said. "She did a horrible, horrible thing. Can't be worse."

    "But you'll find out what the price to pay is," Trump added. "There'll be a price. It's going to be a mental institution or jail or something...it's too bad."

  8. No decision yet on retrial, prosecutor sayspublished at 20:01 BST

    Plymouth District Attorney Cruz says "there will be no decisions made today" regarding retrying the case against Lindsay Clancy.

    He says he will meet the rest of their legal team to decide, and he thanked the jury for their service in the matter.

    "The facts are Lindsay Clancy killed her three children and the evidence suggested to us that she was in control of her actions when she committed those homicides," he says.

  9. Plymouth district attorney speaking to press nowpublished at 19:57 BST

    Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy CruzImage source, Reuters

    We're now hearing from Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz.

    He praises the prosecutors and investigators who worked on this case, and says trying this case was seeking justice for Cora, Dawson and Callan Clancy.

    "This is a case about three children who died a violent and horrific death at the hands of the person who should have loved them the most," he says.

  10. Court adjourns for the daypublished at 19:34 BST

    The court clerk repeats to the courtroom that the case has resulted in a mistrial, with the next date for a status hearing set for 29 September.

    And with that, court is adjourned.

  11. Disbelief in the courtroompublished at 19:30 BST

    Ione Wells
    Reporting from court in Massachusetts

    It is surprisingly silent in the courtroom.

    I think many people are in disbelief that after a brutal trial that lasted weeks, and more than 36 hours of deliberation, there is no verdict in the end. It is hard to see Lindsay Clancy’s expression. Others in the courtroom, including her mother, have neutral expressions. Her lawyer is making every last ditch attempt to appeal this.

    The jury have been dismissed, but we are still in session here.

  12. Clancy and Reddington look on as mistrial declaredpublished at 19:29 BST

    Lindsay Clancy and her attorney Kevin Reddington looked on as Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial and discharged the jury.

    Clancy was expressionless but Reddington looked visibly upset by the decision, removing his glasses and looking forward.

  13. Clancy's lawyer pushed back until the last minutepublished at 19:28 BST

    Clancy's defence lawyer Kevin Reddington continued to push back until the last minute, insisting Judge William Sullivan had the power to dismiss the one holdout juror.

    "Unfortunately, they’re not holding out based on a good-faith issue," he said.

    The judge denied the request, and proceeded to officially declare a mistrial in the case of Lindsay Clancy. The jurors have now been sent home, with no further obligations in this trial.

  14. Judge declares mistrialpublished at 19:26 BST
    Breaking

    "At this point, I'm going to declare that the jury is deadlocked, and I'm going to declare a mistrial," Judge William Sullivan tells the jury, discharging them.

  15. Judge calls jury back into courtpublished at 19:23 BST

    Judge Sullivan has called members of the jury back to the courtroom.

  16. Emergency appeal denied, mistrial to be declared, judge sayspublished at 19:22 BST
    Breaking

    Judge William Sullivan says the defence team's emergency appeal asking the the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court to intervene has been denied.

    The temporary pause on court proceedings is now lifted, the judge adds, and he intends to bring the jury in and proceed in declaring a mistrial.

  17. Court is back in sessionpublished at 19:19 BST

    After an hour-long delay and an hour-long break for lunch, court is back in session with Judge William Sullivan on the bench.

    The defendant and her family, lawyers, and dozens of members of the press have all filed back into the courtroom.

    We're now waiting for an update on what happens next.

    Click watch live to stream the proceedings yourself.

  18. Headed back into the courtroompublished at 19:18 BST

    Ione Wells
    Reporting from court in Massachusetts

    We're going back into court now.

  19. Clancy and lawyers have last-ditch appeal hearing before Massachusetts high courtpublished at 18:59 BST

    Clancy and her attorney just appeared virtually before a Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court justice, urging the higher court to consider intervening to prevent a mistrial today.

    Clancy and lawyer Kevin Reddington appeared together on Zoom from the courthouse, and speaking on their behalf was another attorney, Dana Goldblatt. Goldblatt argued that the Supreme Court justice should take action, as one of the jurors is refusing to follow the law and Judge William Sullivan is refusing to correct the situation properly.

    After the brief hearing, Justice Dalila Argaez Wendlandt said the documents were quick and well put together, but she needs time to make a decision.

    We will bring you more on that when we know the outcome.

  20. 'Lindsay Clancy cannot be the poster child', one mum sayspublished at 18:47 BST

    Brandon Drenon

    The Lindsay Clancy trial has not only captivated massive interest, it has also been massively divisive.

    Crowds of supporters in pink shirts have flocked to the courthouse to show their support, some carrying notes in pink envelopes for Clancy, empathising with her struggles as a mother.

    Others, like Nicole Russell, who have tuned into the trial from afar, have watched the outpouring of support in disbelief and “shock”.

    “Death by strangulation is very specific. It's very gruesome,” Russell said, referring to the evidence of how Clancy killed her kids that shaped her views on the trial.

    “So to know that her children's last face they saw was her trying to kill them, that started to, I think, just make the crimes very real to me,” Russell, who has four children, continued.

    “Lindsay Clancy cannot be the poster child of what difficult motherhood looks like, because millions of mothers give birth to children and endure all kinds of hardship, and they do not hurt their children,” she said. “Those are the heroes.”