Swifties, BTS ARMY, Whovians. Being a fan of something can give you a sense of identity that’s often strengthened by finding your community on social media.
But does social media change your relationship with the thing you love?
There’s no doubt fan movements are full of devoted people, and they’ll share their passion with the world online - even if their opinion of the thing they love turns negative. But in an age when fandoms are more visible than ever before, can their views actually influence their favourite creators?
BBC Bitesize Other Side of the Story spoke to Dr Bethan Jones of Cardiff University about fan power and whether social media gives them more say over the things they love.

Have fans ever influenced the thing they love?
The answer is… yes, they have. And it predates social media.
One example of fan power comes from Sherlock Holmes. Author Arthur Conan Doyle killed Holmes off in a story called 'The Final Problem'.
When it was published, 20,000 readers cancelled their Strand Magazine subscriptions in protest - men even wore black armbands to mourn the detective. Bowing to pressure, Conan Doyle brought him back a few years later.

Fast forward 100 years, and we come to one of the first ‘online’ fandoms. TV sci-fi series The X-Files originally ran from 1993 to 2002, and many fans became early users of the internet. Dr Jones loved the series herself, and recalls, “A lot of fans would go on message boards, and writers would lurk in those spaces, so they would read what fans were saying.”
The series would make nods to fan contributions, the most significant example coming in 2001, when a popular fan fiction writer named Leyla Harrison passed away. Later that year, the series introduced a new character, named Leyla Harrison in her honour.
Dr Jones suggests TV production is a creative area that it makes sense fans would influence: “It's an ongoing process quite a lot of the time, you've got multiple seasons. There's more scope for fans to change or influence the creators and the production.”
Social media can make this influence more visible. Twenty years on from The X-Files, Doctor Who fans began speculating online that a romance could develop between the Thirteenth Doctor and her companion Yaz.
In fact, this hadn’t been planned, but actors Jodie Whittaker and Mandip Gill, and showrunner Chris Chibnall, became aware of the for ‘Thasmin’ and decided to develop it into a storyline.

Does social media give fans more power?
It would be easy to think social media has increased fans’ power because it makes it easier to voice an opinion and perhaps send it straight to a creator.
Dr Jones remembers, “Back in the day, if you wanted to share your thoughts, you'd have to write a letter, which is a long process in the first place. Then you'd have to post it off, and it would take however long to get there… then you might get a reply months down the line.”
But communication isn’t the same as influence. The artist is still their own person, and as Dr Jones points out, we shouldn’t assume they are running their own socials: “It's more than likely going to be their team that is reading through it, potentially replying.”
Social media hasn't necessarily given fans more influence, but it may have brought changes for artists by creating demand to stay more visible to fans. It also gives them plenty of ways to meet that demand. Taylor Swift may not have a new album to release, but she can post interviews or photos from studio sessions - and even put out a few new songs for an expanded edition of her last album.
Does that extra demand result from fans being online? Dr Jones isn’t so sure: “I don't know whether it's demand from the fandom or the managers, studios and producers, saying, 'We need to we need to release more…' but using fans as an excuse for that."

Is AI going to change fandom?
Two major developments on the horizon for young fans in the UK are the government’s looming social media ban for under-16s and the rise of AI. What impact could these have on fan habits and how creators respond?
Dr Jones suggests real-life events could become more of a focus. For science-fiction fans, “Conventions are becoming a lot more popular. They've been around for a long time, but it's only in the last decade, maybe 20 years, that they've become more mainstream.”
Meanwhile, huge demand remains for live concerts, with the organisers of Glastonbury 2027 recently warning fans about the risk of scams.
Dr Jones is also sure AI will continue to have an impact on fandoms. Fan communities are already seeing AI-generated fan art, fiction or videos emerging - and dividing opinion.
Some argue prompting a piece of art or fiction into being isn’t the same as human creativity, or feel it is wrong to use a system trained from copyrighted works. “There's lots of discussion within fan spaces about the ethics of that. Fan fiction and fan art draw on copyrighted images and texts, but not in the same way that AI does.”
Fan behaviour evolves with technology, but it remains to be seen how different creators will respond to it. One thing that will stay constant, however, is fans' passion for the things they love, and that's been the same throughout history. Just ask Arthur Conan Doyle.


Not sure if the news you’re seeing on social media is true or false? Can you always tell if the things you see online are real or fake?
Learn how to get the other side of the story with our quizzes, videos and explainers about media skills and viral trends including popular food myths.
Why was there so much speculation about the next James Bond?
Robert Pattinson, Callum Turner and Josh O'Connor were all said to be in the running - but why did we care so much?

Why can fans be so negative about the thing they love?
How bias, gatekeeping and rosy retrospection can reveal itself

Other Side of the Story
Back to our homepage for more quizzes and explainers about fake news, viral trends and media skills.
