Mo Salah's social media post is not "becoming of a Liverpool legend," insists the supporter Ste Plunkett from Redmen TV.
Salah, who will be hanging up his boots for Liverpool after nine seasons at the Merseyside club, said his side must return to a "heavy metal attacking team that opponents fear".
Plunkett believes the timing of his post, which came after Arne Slot's side were defeated 4-2 by Aston Villa on Friday night is "dreadful".
Speaking to BBC Radio Merseyside Plunkett said: "I don't agree with what he's done, I don't agree with the way he's done it, on Instagram, 62 million followers, it's really not helpful.
"The timing's dreadful, the season's not over, he's still a Liverpool player and I don't think that's becoming of a Liverpool legend. It's not what we've done in years gone by, I don't think we want to do it in years to come either.
"The timing is dreadful but the context is understandable. It's not what you do when you're a Liverpool legend."
While Plunkett feels there is some validity in the comments Salah made, he reckons it unveils a bigger problem for the club as many current players 'liked' the forward's post.
"That is a major concern if you're a manager," added Plunkett.
"Because if you don't believe that, you don't act upon it, you certainly don't 'like' it. You sit there in your dressing room and say 'I probably wouldn't have done that Mo, that's not great,' but it's past and present players that have liked it.
"It's a really bad look for the football club, it's really, really dodgy times for Slot at the moment because if you're sitting in Fenway Sports Park looking at that, you're looking at it thinking he's lost the dressing room because the players agree with what Salah is saying.
"They probably perhaps think the timing's bad and how it was done is even worse but I think the fundamental comments within that statement, if they agree with it, Slot's got big problems."
Thirty-three-year-old Salah has called time after winning nine major trophies with Liverpool, as well as breaking individual records for the club.
"Salah when he breaks a record, is the first person to celebrate, he knows all about where he is in the pantheon of football greats, and records and trophies and all that good stuff," said Plunkett.
"Salah's very, very self-centered. Salah is a brand and he's the champion of that brand and I get that.
"That selfish streak can sometimes be sort of overzealous and that's probably what it is for me, a bit of overzealousness in his self-protection and his self-preservation."
Listen to the full conversation on BBC Sounds or by clicking play on the clip above