Is it time for Trafford to de-throne Pickford?

James Trafford and Jordan Pickford training for EnglandImage source, Getty Images
ByPat Nevin
Former Everton winger and presenter
  • Published

Justin asked: Is it time for James Trafford to be England's number one, or is that unfair on Jordan Pickford who has done little wrong? Does loyalty matter if there might be someone better now?

Pat said: It is understandable that people will fret over this decision about Trafford or Pickford. Each keeper will have his own fans who are adamant their man is the best. Backing Trafford might even be the hipster position to take in that he is the younger man, the outsider and the new kid on the block.

Old-school football attitudes tend however to favour sticking with a goalkeeper until he starts letting you down and then viciously dump him. In between the sticks, the shirt is usually yours until you drop the ball. It is particularly painful when a keeper is replaced in international or domestic football because, unlike other players, there is no chance of getting back in the team in another position. When you are out, you are out.

Having said that, there are many examples of international managers having a couple of world-class keepers and rotating them to keep them both relatively happy. Unai Simon and David Raya are a perfect example with Spain.

And here lies the answer to your question. We all want to know who is number one, but Thomas Tuchel is just delighted he has two to call on in case one gets injured or has a drop in form.

Tuchel should, and probably will, fluff the question deliberately because he wants to keep them both on board and committed. Announcing a definitive number one above the other doesn't help his situation. It just undermines the understudy.

Tuchel rightly believes that no player has an automatic right to play. No matter who you are or where you play, if you stop doing the job well, then you are out. Just ask Jude Bellingham about that.

So both keepers will have to continue to be at their best to be part of this incredible team.

Pat Nevin writes weekly in the Football Extra newsletter. If you're outside the UK and would like to receive it, sign up here.