'Heavyweights clash on new-look road to Sam Maguire'

Kerry captain Gavin White lifts the Sam Maguire Cup in 2025 and Donegal's joint-captain Shane O'Donnell with the Division One league trophy for 2026Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Kerry and Donegal have beaten each other in the two previous finals they have contested

ByDavid Mohan
BBC Sport NI journalist
  • Published

If ever there was an ideal way to kick-start the new-look All-Ireland Senior Football Championship, the GAA landed on their feet when the draw produced a repeat of last year's final with champions Kerry hosting Donegal on Saturday [15:00 BST].

Killarney's Fitzgerald Stadium is one of the GAA's most picturesque venues, with MacGillicuddy's Reeks sitting majestically in the background - and it is hoped the action on the field this weekend matches the surroundings.

Last year, it was Kerry celebrating a 39th Sam Maguire Cup success, producing a sublime performance to deny Donegal just a third All-Ireland title with 10 points to spare on a day when Jack O'Connor's men were at their imperious best.

Gaelic football's new rules with two-pointers and added space in the attacking zone suited the Kingdom perfectly and Donegal simply had no answer to the Munster champions.

The nature of the performance led many to suggest this was the beginning of a new dynasty in Kerry football and it may well prove to be the case, but Donegal returned the serve in this year's Division One league final, romping to a 13-point win at Croke Park.

Will that have a bearing this weekend?

Not if you believe the respective camps after the league final. Donegal boss Jim McGuinness stressed the league campaign was about developing squad depth, while O'Connor felt his team was "a bit lethargic and tired" after a thrilling draw against Armagh the previous week.

Defeat was "not the end of the world", O'Connor added.

Donegal's Finnbarr Roarty is challenged by Kerry's Micheál Burns during this year's league finalImage source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Donegal were a step ahead in March's Division One league final

Both sides were much changed from their All-Ireland final meeting, with Donegal fielding 10 starters in both to Kerry's nine.

For Donegal, Hugh McFadden and Jason McGee were promoted to the starting line-up in March after substitute appearances last year, and Finnbarr Roarty came on as a sub in the league final after being deemed unable to start due to illness.

Oisin Gallen and Ciaran Moore came back in for the shock defeat by Down in the Ulster Championship, while Max Campbell and Shea Malone have emerged as new options with Patrick McBrearty one key figure missing this year with injury forcing him to call time on his career.

That loss to Down in Letterkenny last month means Donegal will have played just one game in the eight weeks between the league final and All-Ireland opener. Does that leave them refreshed or under cooked?

They were out-played in last year's All-Ireland final, but in the league decider, they showed something different with goalkeeper Gavin Mulreany taking on added defensive duties, while the curve ball of taking Caolan McColgan to shadow David Clifford proved inspired.

Have they shown their hand now, as there is no doubt Kerry will come up with fresh ideas to redress the balance? Perhaps the past four weeks have given McGuinness and his coaching staff more time to build towards an assault on the big prize which is undoubtedly their focus this year after going so close in 2025.

David Clifford celebrates Kerry's 2025 All-Ireland final winImage source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Kerry were celebrating in last year's All-Ireland final

Kerry may have fallen flat in March, but few will write off the Kindom's chances of back to back All-Irelands.

They moved through the Munster Championship with little fuss on their way to a sixth-straight title and will have confidence in their ability to peak at the right time.

In the final against Cork, they may have started just seven who began last year's All-Ireland final, but four substitutes from last July - Evan Loone, Tadhg Morley, Micheál Burns, Diarmuid O'Connor - started against the Rebels.

Gavin White and Dylan Geaney's return, plus the influence of Tony Brosnan when introduced, suggests Kerry are ready to step things up a gear.

However, they are now also sweating on the fitness of Paudie Clifford - withdrawn at half-time in the Munster final due to a hamstring strain - and Paul Geaney, with the pair joining Seán O'Shea, Joe O'Connor, Tom O'Sullivan Brian Ó Beaglaoich, Graham O'Sullivan and goalkeeper Shane Ryan who have been absent.

Not ideal for Kerry entering a condensed championship and one in which the defeated teams from the opening round will find themselves one further loss away from elimination.

New format asks different questions

Saturday may not be the last time we see these teams square off in 2026 due to the new format, and not necessarily in the final either.

Saturday's winner will move through to Round 2A with the eight defeated teams from Round One into 2B.

Those four games in 2A will produce four quarter-finalists, with the losers playing the winners of 2B for the remaining quarter-final slots.

Repeat pairings from earlier in the competition will be avoided where possible, but the deeper teams go into the competition, there is the possibility they could meet again before the final, so is this just part three for the year, or will the winner lay a hammer blow to the other's hopes of glory in late July?

While Kerry enter the championship as favourites and Donegal one place behind, can either afford to hold anything back this week, despite the safety net of a second chance?

Can Donegal reel David Clifford in again, just like they did in March? Can Kerry find a way to reestablish dominance around the middle, which was a major reason for their Sam Maguire success last year?

While the personnel is largely the same, these teams have been on a journey since last July. We have questions as to where they sit just now and by Saturday evening, we'll have some answers.