Are we really in charge?
Do we make our own decisions, or are we puppets of our biological processes? CrowdScience listener Mohammed has been wondering whether he really has free will.
Have you ever found yourself doing something – perhaps getting a glass of water, eating a snack, or even sitting on the toilet – without remembering making the decision to do it? CrowdScience listener Mohammed certainly has. It’s left him wondering: does he really have free will, or is he a puppet of his biological processes?
To try and find the answer, we start in the brain. Presenter Caroline Steel meets neuroscientist Uri Maoz, from Chapman University in the US, to explore the controversial research into what happens when we make decisions. Does neuroscience say that we are free to make our own choices, or does our brain make decisions outside of our consciousness?
Then there’s our guts - they’re home to trillions of microbes; independent living creatures that we couldn’t live without. But could these tiny organisms influence more than our digestion? Harriët Schellekens, from University College Cork in Ireland, shares her cutting-edge research into the surprising ways our microbes shape us.
And perhaps some of us are more "in charge" than others. Caroline visits Sarah Garfinkel at University College London in the UK, to have her interoception tested - her ability to sense what’s happening inside her body. How closely is she tuned into what's going on inside her gut, and why might that matter?
Meanwhile, at King’s College London, health psychologist Lauren Heathcote is exploring how this internal sense could be used in therapy. Caroline meets cancer patient Nadia Haynes to discover how learning to listen to her body has actually changed her sense of control.
Presenter: Caroline Steel
Producer: Katie Tomsett
Editor Ben Motley
(Photo: Close-up Of Businessman's Hands - stock photo Credit: AndreyPopov via Getty Images)
On radio
More episodes
Previous
Featured
.
Broadcasts
- Today19:32GMTBBC World Service
- Monday01:32GMTBBC World Service except Americas and the Caribbean
- Monday04:32GMTBBC World Service Australasia, Americas and the Caribbean, South Asia & East Asia only
- Monday08:32GMTBBC World Service
- Monday12:32GMTBBC World Service Australasia, East and Southern Africa, News Internet & West and Central Africa only
Podcast
![]()
CrowdScience
Answering your questions about life, Earth and the universe

